Which 90s Hidden Gem Deserves Your Vote? Four Albums That Slipped Through the Cracks

A heavy southern rock R.E.M., an experimental supergroup fever dream, punk legends adapting to the alternative decade, and a Grammy winner’s commercial disaster. Which 90s story calls to you?

Ever wonder about the albums that almost made it? The ones that had all the right ingredients but somehow never found their moment? Our community has served up four fascinating deep cuts that deserve a closer listen—each one a story of missed opportunities and hidden brilliance. The winner will be featured on the next episode of Dig Me Out podcast.

---

Drivin’ N Cryin’ - Fly Me Courageous

The Southern Rock That Time Forgot

Keith Miller nailed it—this does sound like “heavy southern rock R.E.M.” Coming out of Atlanta’s legendary music scene, Drivin’ N Cryin’ crafted something special with Fly Me Courageous. The album hit peak commercial success for the band, but only going gold tells you everything about how crowded 1991 was with alternative rock breaking through.

What’s fascinating is the timing. Released during the Persian Gulf War, the title track accidentally became a military anthem , with pilots literally listening to it before takeoff . But beneath that patriotic interpretation lies a more complex song about confronting aggression rather than celebrating it . The album perfectly captures that southern gothic sensibility that R.E.M. had pioneered—mixing driving rock with country influences and that distinctly Georgian melancholy .

“Build a Fire” showcases their range with its punk-meets-shuffle rhythm and unexpected rap sequence, while “The Innocent” opens with a Constitution parody that cuts deep into political hypocrisy . This was Atlanta rock at its most authentic—before the scene got swallowed by major label expectations.

Fantômas - Fantômas

When Supergroups Get Weird

Patrick Testa’s description as “unique” barely scratches the surface. This isn’t just experimental—it’s Mike Patton leading a masterclass in controlled chaos . With Slayer’s Dave Lombardo on drums, Melvins’ Buzz Osborne on guitar, and Mr. Bungle’s Trevor Dunn on bass, you’d expect fireworks. What you get instead is something closer to a fever dream .

The album unfolds like a comic book (hence the “pages” instead of songs), with 30 tracks clocking in at just 42 minutes . It’s “dada-metal”—absurdist art disguised as extreme music . Patton abandons conventional lyrics entirely, turning his voice into an instrument of pure expression, from ultra-high screeches to guttural growls .

What makes it brilliant isn’t just the technical prowess (though Lombardo’s drumming is otherworldly), it’s how it pushes metal into uncharted territory . This influenced everyone from Tool to Slipknot , proving that sometimes the most inaccessible art creates the longest ripples.

Ramones - Mondo Bizarro

Punk Veterans Navigate the 90s

Eric Peterson asks the right question—what happens when punk originators enter the alternative decade? Mondo Bizarro represents the Ramones at a crossroads, introducing C.J. Ramone on bass while Dee Dee’s songwriting still haunts the album .

The record peaked at a disappointing #190 on the Billboard 200—their lowest chart position ever . But dig deeper and you’ll find gems like “Poison Heart” (a Dee Dee composition that became their first Top 10 modern rock hit in years) and “Censorshit”, Joey’s furious response to Tipper Gore’s censorship crusade .

What’s remarkable is how the band adapted without losing their essence. “Touring” is a Beach Boys tribute that somehow works perfectly, while their cover of The Doors’ “Take It as It Comes” feels like punk’s acknowledgment of its classic rock roots . Johnny Ramone later dismissed it with a “C” grade, but that misses the point—this is punk legends refusing to go quietly into the 90s alternative rock explosion.

Paula Cole - Amen

When Success Becomes a Prison

Keith A. Badje poses an intriguing puzzle: “Listen to ‘I Believe in Love’ and try to figure out why it wasn’t huge.” The numbers tell a stark story—This Fire sold over 2 million copies , while Amen moved just 116,000 .

So what happened? Cole made the classic sophomore album mistake of zigging when everyone expected her to zag. This Fire delivered accessible folk-pop that dominated radio and MTV. Amen featured electronic experiments, hip-hop elements (including scratches from DJ Premier), and longer, more complex song structures .

“I Believe in Love” has all the emotional punch of her biggest hits, but it’s wrapped in more adventurous production that radio programmers couldn’t easily categorize . The song builds beautifully, showcasing Cole’s incredible vocal range, yet it never found an audience beyond her core fanbase.

The album represents that tricky artistic moment when success gives you freedom to experiment, but the industry wants you to repeat what worked . Cole chose growth over formula, and commercially, it backfired. Twenty-five years later, though, Amen sounds ahead of its time—a bridge between 90s alternative and the genre-blending that would dominate the 2000s.