There was a time when music was an experience—not just something you put on in the background. You’d sit with an album, reading the liner notes, letting every track unfold like a story. Dream Theater was one of those bands that rewarded deep listening. Their music was built for the dreamers and the overthinkers—people who wanted songs that could stretch for ten minutes and still keep you hooked. Even if you weren’t following their prog-metal journey in the 90s, there’s a good chance you felt that same wonder from albums like OK Computer or Scenes from a Memory. Now, with Parasomnia, they’re back with a concept that dives into the strange world of sleep and dreams. But is this latest offering one of their essential chapters? Let’s see what the critics think.
What Works
Reunion with Mike Portnoy Brings Renewed Energy
The return of founding drummer Mike Portnoy after a 15-year absence has infused the band with a rejuvenated spirit. Critics note a sharper-edged heaviness and a cohesive chemistry reminiscent of their earlier works. Classic Rock observes, “There’s a rejuvenated feel to this reunion album,” highlighting the band’s refreshed dynamic.
Thematic Cohesion and Conceptual Depth
Parasomnia delves into sleep disturbances, weaving a narrative that critics find both engaging and thought-provoking. Loudwire praises the album’s “connective thematic tissue,” noting how the concept permeates both lyrics and instrumentation, creating a unified listening experience.
Standout Tracks Showcase Musical Mastery
Tracks like “Night Terror” and “A Broken Man” have garnered acclaim for their intricate compositions and emotional depth. Glide Magazine highlights “A Broken Man” for its “staccato riffing met with Portnoy’s punishing attack,” emphasizing the band’s technical prowess and storytelling ability.
Nods to Classic Albums
Fans will appreciate subtle callbacks to earlier works, providing a sense of nostalgia while exploring new musical landscapes. Loudwire points out references to Metropolis Pt. 2: Scenes From a Memory, noting lyrical and musical motifs that pay homage to the band’s legacy.
👉 Want to know if Parasomnia is really worth the deep dive?
Keep reading with a 7-day free trial
Subscribe to Dig Me Out to keep reading this post and get 7 days of free access to the full post archives.