Killswitch Engage’s This Consequence: A Timeless Return or Just More of the Same?

Metalcore’s most influential band returns—does This Consequence add to their legacy? Critics are divided on whether this album pushes the genre forward.

You ever put on an album and immediately feel that rush—the kind that reminds you why you fell in love with heavy music in the first place? Maybe it was that first bone-rattling riff, a chorus that hit right in the gut, or lyrics that felt like they were written just for you. For over two decades, Killswitch Engage has delivered those moments, blending fury and melody in a way few bands can.

Now, they’re back with This Consequence, an album that’s already stirring up discussion. Some critics are calling it a powerful return to form, while others feel it plays things a little too safe. After all these years, does Killswitch Engage still have that fire, or is this just another solid chapter in their story?

Let’s break it down and see what the critics are saying—but more importantly, we want to hear from you. Does This Consequence live up to the band’s legacy? Drop your thoughts in the comments.

What Works

Energetic Return to Form: Critics note that This Consequence reignites the intensity that Killswitch Engage is known for. The Aquarian Weekly describes the album as “another melodic metalcore masterpiece,” highlighting its “harrowing instrumental intensity and cutthroat lyrics” that reflect the current emotional state of society.

Standout Tracks: Several songs have been singled out for their impact. “Abandon Us” is praised as an “instant-impact wake-up call,” setting a powerful tone for the album. “Forever Aligned” is noted for its “flawless fusion of intense riffs, melodic passages, and varied vocal dynamics,” showcasing the band’s evolved heavier elements while retaining their signature sound.

Vocal Prowess: Vocalist Jesse Leach delivers a performance that resonates deeply. Hot Metal Magazine observes that Leach is “on fire, both vocally and lyrically,” bringing a renewed energy to the band’s sound.

Musical Craftsmanship: The band’s technical skills are evident throughout the album. MXDWN commends the balance between “technical prowess and raw emotion,” noting that the album “showcases the band’s ability to balance technical prowess with raw emotion.”

Thematic Depth: Lyrically, the album tackles pressing societal issues. The Aquarian Weekly highlights how the record “offers sequential stanzas of spiritual inquisition,” prompting listeners to reflect on the current state of culture and community.

---

👉 Some critics love it, others aren’t sold. Read the full review to see if This Consequence lives up to the hype.