Suggest an Album

How did a record this close to our tastes get past both of us?

We were looking. That’s the part that bothers us.

In 2006, we weren’t taking a break from music or waiting for somebody to hand us a playlist. We were making records, buying records, reading about records, and following the little trails that led from one band to another. An unfamiliar name attached to a familiar sound was practically an invitation.

Yet this one never arrived.

Now we have a San Diego band with huge guitars, restless keyboards, an artier strain of emo in the vocals, and a mix by Ken Andrews. For two people who love Failure, that last detail makes the omission feel almost personal.

A Familiar Name and an Unfamiliar Band

The Andrews connection gives us a way into the record but It doesn’t explain everything inside it.

First Wave Hello formed in San Diego in 2004, initially exploring an experimental electronic direction. Their first full-length arrived in 2006, with Andrews involved in its production history and specifically credited by the band as mixer. William Nephew and Christian Cummings handled recording. Those distinctions matter, because hearing a familiar sonic signature isn’t permission to assign one person every decision on an album.

Still, we understand why the Failure comparison comes so quickly.

The drums sound enormous. The guitars occupy real space. Dissonance appears, but it doesn’t turn the whole picture into a blur. We can hear the layers even when we can’t immediately identify which instrument is making a particular sound.

That relationship extended beyond the mixing desk. First Wave Hello later opened for Andrews on his solo tour and served as his backing band.

What surprises us is how accomplished the record sounds given its independent origins. A recognizable mixer can sharpen a band’s identity but the identity still has to be there.

On this record, we keep finding it in the keyboards.

The Keyboards Are Fire

Take the synths away and we would be discussing a different band.

That’s our strongest response to The Lord & its Penguin. The guitars are substantial, sometimes huge, but the keyboards determine how the music moves around them. They add grit beneath the low end, stretch a passage into something more expansive, or introduce an unfamiliar noise that changes the emotional temperature.

We hear some of the art-rock side of emo in the vocal delivery, closer in spirit to Cursive or No Knife than a straightforward confessional approach. But the instrumental setting keeps pushing the record toward space rock. That tension gives it character.

The impressive part is the band’s ability to choose sounds that belong together.

We’ve messed around with keyboards enough to appreciate how easily a part can feel pasted onto a rock arrangement. A patch jumps out for the wrong reason. A piano suddenly changes the entire atmosphere. A synth competes with the guitar instead of extending it.

Here, we hear tones meeting at the edges. Is that roughness coming from the bass, a keyboard, or a guitar effect? Sometimes we can’t tell and that’s why it works.

The result can feel polished and strange at once. We don’t get the sense that every abrasive sound has been removed. Instead, the abrasive sounds have been given somewhere to sit. The mix lets the band be dense without making density the only thing we notice.

Slow Songs With Something Moving Inside Them

“Our Best Policy” doesn’t need speed to feel powerful.

Its kick and snare give us that slow, booming momentum we love in this kind of music. There’s weight behind the beat, but there’s also movement.

“Everything Automatic” offers a different kind of interruption: a keyboard sound that suggests a warning alarm. It’s a small detail with a big effect. Just when we think we understand the record’s palette, something cuts across it.

That matters because so much of the album lives in a mid-tempo range. Leaving space can expose an arrangement’s weaknesses. Here, the keyboards often make that space worth listening into.

Sometimes they supply the central melody. Sometimes they answer another instrument. Sometimes they become the floor underneath everything else.

“Lay Down” pulls the sound toward a more restrained, atmospheric setting. We hear a connection to National Skyline, particularly that meeting of electronic and organic textures. Elsewhere, the breadth suggests Hum, while a few sharper electronic edges bring Nine Inch Nails into the conversation without turning this into an industrial record.

The attraction is in those changes. We aren’t waiting only for a chorus. A repeated keyboard figure or an unexpected sound is the thing that brings us back.

Jim’s pick changed what we made this week. If you want a hand in future episodes, join the community: paid members vote in album polls, and the winner becomes a full podcast episode.

Subscribe now

We Were Looking for This. We Still Didn’t Find It.

The frustrating thing about rediscovery is realizing you would have loved the discovery sooner.

We keep coming back to 2006 because this record doesn’t sound like something that required us to develop entirely new tastes. We already had the reference points. We were already interested in heavy, atmospheric rock and bands finding ways to combine electronics with guitars.

Our routes into music were different. There were record-store listening booths. There were magazines, iTunes, and eMusic. There were independent releases in our collections, not just whatever had the largest promotional budget.

So why didn’t this one reach us?

There may also be something in the music’s position between camps. It’s melodic, but not consistently built around immediate vocal hooks. It’s adventurous, but not always as strange as the more experimental records we were buying.

That leaves it in a difficult middle: accessible enough to suggest a wider audience, dense enough to ask that audience for patience.

When the Atmosphere Starts Asking Too Much

A beautiful sound can still wear out its welcome.

Our biggest criticism isn’t that the album contains songs we hate. But enjoying the ingredients doesn’t guarantee attention across the full 58 minutes.

The density accumulates. So do the introductions.

We start noticing a pattern: a small rhythmic entrance, a passage that feels like a preliminary verse, and then the song properly getting underway. Used once, that can create anticipation. Repeated across a stretch of an album, it can make us wish the band would occasionally just open the door and walk in.

There’s a sequencing issue, too. The more immediate hooks seem concentrated toward the front, while the record grows more demanding as it continues. That’s a legitimate artistic choice. It also means the listener’s job gets harder rather than easier.

“Nothing Like Nausea” lifts the tempo, but it doesn’t fully supply the bruising change of pace we find ourselves wanting. One really direct, louder, heavier song might have altered the album’s proportions.

A headphone record can reward concentration and still test it. Both things can be true. That’s where this conversation gets more interesting than simply praising the mix.

The Verdict: How Much Immersion Is Enough?

The element we love most is also the element that divided our community.

One listener came to the band through the Andrews connection and embraced the record. Another found the vocal treatment and abundance of synths difficult to stay with. Sometimes the sound itself is the obstacle.

Where does it land for you?

Listen to the full episode for our verdict and the community results, then drop a comment with the song that makes your case. Join the community to help decide future coverage. In our album polls, paid members choose the winner that becomes the next full episode and feature.

Subscribe now

Episode Highlights

• 01:44: Jim’s patron pick, the unfamiliar band that lands squarely in our listening wheelhouse

• 03:21: Ken Andrews connection, why the mixing credit immediately catches our attention

• 04:37: Community reactions, the synth-heavy sound wins an advocate and loses another listener

• 06:47: Keyboards as architecture, the tones that give the album its identity

• 12:09: Our Best Policy, slow drums with weight and forward motion

• 13:00: Everything Automatic, an alarm-like keyboard sound disrupts expectations

• 19:06: Lay Down, electronic and organic textures bring National Skyline to mind

• 21:58: Density and repetition, when the introductions start testing our attention

• 24:39: Nothing Like Nausea, a tempo change that doesn’t quite supply the desired release

• 28:13: Independent ambition, accomplished sound without a conventional label launch

• 30:25: The 2006 blind spot, how a record this compatible with our tastes escaped us

• 35:00: Final verdict, our assessments and the community results

This is how your record collection becomes part of the show. Listeners suggest the albums, we build the ballot, and paid members choose what gets the deep dive. The winner becomes a podcast episode. Whether you’re making the case for a neglected favorite or asking us to hear a familiar classic differently, your participation changes what gets made.

Subscribe now

In the 90s we started buying alternative records. That didn’t mean we stopped wanting a guitar solo, a voice with some miles on it, or a chorus you could sing before the song was over.

October’s ’90s ballot lives in that part of the collection. Killer Dwarfs arrived in 1990 with Dirty Weapons. Kik Tracee released No Rules in 1991. Stephen Pearcy’s Arcade put a familiar voice into a new band in 1993. And Buckcherry closed out the decade with a 1999 debut that put “Lit Up” on the radio. Different moments, different prospects, same refusal to put the guitars away.

So let’s get past whether these records were early, late, or out of step. Which one deserves a proper listen now?

Killer Dwarfs — Dirty Weapons (1990)

Some nominations arrive with a thoughtful recommendation. Keith P Miller’s arrives with a challenge:

“This is one of the most perfect hard rock albums that almost no one has ever heard.”

That’s a high bar. Exactly the sort of claim we like putting a whole episode behind.

Dirty Weapons was the Canadian band’s fourth album, not a debut from newcomers trying to catch the last train. There’s experience behind this one—and a case for the kind of melodic hard rock where the guitar sound and the chorus are supposed to carry equal weight. Writer Tom Beaujour, co-author of Nöthin’ but a Good Time, has singled it out as well, praising the production and arguing that Killer Dwarfs never got their fair shake.

Keith’s nomination gives us the question worth testing: is this simply a record more people should know, or the nearly front-to-back keeper he says it is?

Arcade — Arcade (1993)

Suggested by Dewey Cole, who pointed straight to the connection:

“Stephen Pearcy from Ratt formed this band shortly after RATT disbanded.”

Pearcy’s voice is the immediate draw, but Arcade wasn’t a solo record with a different logo. Cinderella drummer Fred Coury joined him, alongside guitarists Donny Syracuse and Frankie Wilsex and bassist Michael Andrews. Their self-titled debut arrived in 1993 with songs including “Nothin’ to Lose,” “Cry No More,” and “Messed Up World.”

That makes this an especially interesting reset. How much familiar identity do you bring into a new band—and how much do you leave behind?

An Arcade episode would let us hear this as more than a Ratt footnote. Does the band establish its own personality? Do the songs give Pearcy somewhere new to go? And how does it land when we stop asking what a hard rock record was supposed to sound like in 1993?

Already have your pick? Cast your vote in the poll below. If you’re reading as a free subscriber, become a paid member to help choose the album we take apart together.

Subscribe now

Kik Tracee — No Rules (1991)

John’s nomination gets right to the frustration:

“Great band, a tad too late for the 80 s but nonetheless great record”

There’s an entire record-store section hiding inside that sentence.

Released in May 1991, No Rules was Kik Tracee’s debut and only full-length studio album. Slaughter bassist Dana Strum produced it, and “Don’t Need Rules” and “You’re So Strange” were among its singles.

The temptation with an album like this is to let the release date explain everything. Too late. Wrong moment. Moving on.

But that doesn’t tell us much about the record.

John’s recommendation asks us to separate the music from the timing. What made Kik Tracee worth hearing in the first place? What distinguishes these songs from the other big-chorus hopefuls? And does No Rules sound like a missed opportunity now that nobody’s waiting to see what happens on MTV next week?

Buckcherry — Buckcherry (1999)

Tim Minneci isn’t promising an overlooked masterpiece. He’s proposing an experiment:

“I haven’t listened to this since it came out. No idea if it will hold up.”

Sometimes that’s the best reason to put a record on the show.

Buckcherry’s debut arrived in April 1999. “Lit Up” spent three weeks at No. 1 on Billboard’s Mainstream Rock Tracks chart, and the album also produced “For the Movies,” “Dead Again,” and “Check Your Head” as singles. This wasn’t just a band insisting there was still an audience for its version of hard rock. It found one.

What happens after “Lit Up”? Does the rest have the personality and songs to bring you back?

Which song on this ballot would you play to win over someone who’s already written the band off? Tell us the track and what they’re missing.

Got another ’90s record you’re still making excuses to play for people? Drop it in the hopper. The next choice starts with what you bring to the pile.

Suggest an Album

Suggest an Album

What if metal’s loudest band is also its most theatrical?

There is no easing into Kings of Metal.

The opening seconds of “Wheels of Fire” arrive at full gallop, far faster and sharper than the cartoonish cover art might lead you to expect. Then Manowar makes its real move: it refuses to stay in one place. A charging opener gives way to the chant-ready title track, then the grand balladry of “Heart of Steel.” Before long, we are hearing choirs, ceremonial piano, dramatic narration, a full-throttle interpretation of “Flight of the Bumblebee,” and enough battle imagery to fill a paperback fantasy shelf.

That range is the record’s real surprise. We came in expecting something closer to a blunt-force, fist-pumping version of classic metal. What we found was a band trying to make every song feel like a scene in an imagined production, somewhere between arena metal, sword-and-sorcery paperback art, and musical theater with amplifiers stacked behind it.

That approach can be ridiculous. It is often supposed to be. The key is whether you agree to the terms.

Manowar asks us to suspend disbelief, step through the castle gate, and accept that every chorus should sound like a declaration from a mountaintop. Once we do, the album becomes strangely inviting. Its bombast does not repel so much as pull us toward the campfire, hand us a sword, and tell us there is a battle at dawn.

Subscribe now

The American band that sounded European

Manowar formed in Auburn, New York, yet Kings of Metal often feels imported from another continent and another century. Joey DeMaio, Eric Adams, Ross “the Boss” Friedman, and Scott Columbus sound less interested in documenting late-1980s America than constructing their own version of European myth and battlefield folklore. The album was recorded at Universal Recording in Chicago, with the Canoldir Male Choir recorded in Birmingham, England.

That contradiction is part of the record’s charm. This is not Iron Maiden, with its detailed historical narratives and carefully researched time travel. Manowar’s world is broader, blurrier, and more proudly invented. Crowns, rings, armies, ale, steel, kings, conquest, and doomed warriors all appear, but they do not always lock into one consistent story.

Instead, the songs build atmosphere. “The Crown and the Ring (Lament of the Kings)” is stately and mournful, as if the band has suddenly wandered into a cathedral. “Kingdom Come” carries an almost AOR-sized melodic sweep beneath its metal armor. “Blood of the Kings” reaches for seven-minute epic territory, where the band seems determined to make every last gesture land with maximum gravity.

This is power metal before the genre had settled into its later habits. You can hear the lineage toward bands such as Blind Guardian, Týr, and the broader fantasy-metal world, but Manowar still sounds uniquely American in its need to declare itself the biggest, loudest, and most definitive version of everything.

The hooks are stronger than the armor

The title track makes the whole case in under four minutes.

“Kings of Metal” is an anthem built around a call-and-response hook so obvious that it barely needs instructions. The song’s joke, if it is a joke, is that Manowar spends its self-coronation anthem insisting that it alone represents “true metal,” while musically landing somewhere closer to a stripped-down Motörhead or AC/DC stomp than a complicated power-metal epic.

That is exactly why it works. The riff is direct, the chant is immediate, and the band’s unblinking seriousness turns the whole thing into a communal ritual. You can imagine a room full of fans shouting it back before the song has reached its second chorus.

But the album has more going on than its slogans suggest. “Heart of Steel” is a towering metal ballad whose choir and large-scale arrangement make it feel much closer to a dramatic showstopper than a standard slow song. “Hail and Kill” has the kind of enormous, battle-ready chorus that explains why this material lives on in Manowar’s concert mythology.

Then there is “Sting of the Bumblebee,” Joey DeMaio’s bass-driven adaptation of Nikolai Rimsky-Korsakov’s “Flight of the Bumblebee.” It is flashy, goofy, technically impressive, and not entirely necessary. But that combination may be the most Manowar thing on the record.

The record’s biggest enemy is its sequence

Kings of Metal has the ingredients of a focused fantasy-metal statement. Its sequencing keeps getting in the way.

The first four songs alone jump from speed metal to chant anthem to power ballad to virtuoso instrumental. The variety is admirable, but it also makes it difficult to settle into an arc. Rather than gathering momentum, the album repeatedly changes costumes before the last scene has landed.

The strangest placement is “The Warriors Prayer,” a spoken fantasy monologue with sound effects that arrives as the ninth track. It has all the qualities of an opening invocation or closing epilogue. Instead, it appears just before the final epic, which makes it feel as though the record has suddenly remembered it needs a plot.

A more deliberate version might open with a shortened “The Warriors Prayer,” charge into “Kings of Metal” or “Hail and Kill,” and let the record gradually become more ceremonial. Even Manowar’s 2014 re-recording, Kings of Metal MMXIV, revised the running order and left “Pleasure Slave” behind.

The variation does make every song distinct. Still, a record this theatrical needs pacing. If you are going to build a kingdom, the rooms should connect.

Where the fantasy breaks down

Manowar’s total commitment is the album’s superpower. It is also the source of its most dated moments.

“Pleasure Slave” is the clear problem. Originally left off the single-LP vinyl edition but included on most CD editions, it is not just uncomfortable because of its lyrics. It also drags the album away from its grand fantasy frame into a strain of 1980s metal sexuality that feels lazy, ugly, and dramatically smaller than the rest of the record.

There are other moments where the band’s obsession with dominance becomes more exhausting than empowering. Manowar does not merely want to play metal. It wants to be the kings of it, louder than every rival, tougher than every rival, more authentic than every rival. That absolutism is part of the fun, until it is not.

Yet there is something oddly compelling about a band that never breaks character. Manowar does not wink. It does not hedge. It does not step outside the costume to reassure us that everybody is in on the joke. The band commits so completely that its silliness becomes a kind of sincerity.

That is why the comparison to fantasy fiction matters. This is escapism on a different scale. Some metal confronts reality, anger, alienation, or personal damage. Kings of Metal walks away from reality and builds a parallel universe with flags, armies, choirs, and a bass solo in the middle of it.

Subscribe now

Our verdict: How much fantasy do you want?

Kings of Metal remains a deeply divisive record, even inside our own conversation.

There is no debate that the playing is formidable, the vocals are huge, and the production gives the material enough scale to support its grandest claims. The album’s appeal comes from its ability to make classic metal feel theatrical, melodic, and surprisingly accessible, even when the imagery promises something far more intimidating.

But the flaws are not minor. The sequencing scatters the momentum. “Pleasure Slave” deserves its reputation as the track to skip. “The Warriors Prayer” feels stranded in the wrong part of the record. And the gap between Manowar’s self-proclaimed “true metal” status and the actual music can raise an eyebrow, especially when the title track’s simple rock-and-roll stomp carries the band’s loudest declaration.

So where do you land?

• Does the album’s theatricality make it more fun, or less credible?

• Would a better sequence turn this into a true front-to-back classic?

• Is “Kings of Metal” a perfect anthem, or Manowar’s funniest contradiction?

• Which song carries the real heart of this record: “Heart of Steel,” “Hail and Kill,” or “Blood of the Kings”?

Listen to the full episode for our final ratings, then drop a comment and tell us whether Manowar earned the throne or merely built the loudest castle. The community vote was unanimous: 100 percent landed on “worthy album.”

Episode Highlights

• 00:48: Gavin Reid joins us with a fantasy-metal pick and a formidable mullet

• 02:02: Why Kings of Metal became the album to test the “what is metal?” debate

• 05:38: The 1988 Atlantic Records release, lineup, and why Manowar felt like a magazine band

• 12:56: The original vinyl versus CD track lists, including the infamous “Pleasure Slave”

• 14:00: “Wheels of Fire,” theatrical vocals, and the unexpected accessibility of Manowar

• 19:58: “Heart of Steel,” choirs, Soviet-scale grandeur, and power metal’s emotional pull

• 26:07: “Kings of Metal,” hooks, call-and-response, and the band’s true-metal claim

• 30:55: Why the album’s sequence undermines its own fantasy-world logic

• 36:06: “Pleasure Slave,” lyrical misfires, and the songs we would remove

• 45:38: The revised Kings of Metal MMXIV track list and what it fixes

• 49:50: Our Album, EP, or Decent Single verdicts

• 53:46: The community’s unanimous verdict and Manowar’s fantasy-fueled fan culture

Suggest an Album

Read more

Released February 18, 1997 through Nothing and Interscope, Lost Highway arrived three days before Lynch’s film reached U.S. theaters. Trent Reznor produced a 23-track, 74-minute listening experience that functions less like a collection of songs and more like a controlled collision between old Hollywood unease, late-90s industrial abrasion, smoky jazz, electronic dread, and rock radio ambition.

A Soundtrack That Feels Like A Movie

The best soundtracks do not merely remind us of scenes. They build their own world.

That is the trick Lost Highway pulls off. Even before the movie’s dream logic, shifting identities, and fractured reality enter the picture, the record creates the sensation of driving at night with nowhere reassuring to stop. The opener, Bowie’s edited “I’m Deranged,” establishes the terms immediately: nervous rhythms, synthetic shadows, a voice that sounds both composed and unmoored.

The record is full of moments that should not coexist. You move from The Smashing Pumpkins and their brooding “Eye” to Badalamenti’s score pieces, then from Barry Adamson’s noir cues to Reed’s “This Magic Moment” without ever fully escaping the same neon-lit bad dream.

That coherence is the real achievement. This should have been a promotional grab bag, the kind of 1990s CD built around a single new song and a pile of contractual obligations. Instead, Reznor and Lynch make the shifts feel intentional. The album’s pop-facing songs act as landmarks, while the score pieces turn the road between them into fog.

Trent Reznor’s 1997 Map

Lost Highway captures the moment when Trent Reznor was not merely one of alternative rock’s biggest names, but one of its most useful curators.

By 1997, The Downward Spiral had made Nine Inch Nails unavoidable. Reznor was also producing Marilyn Manson, experimenting with darker electronic textures, and helping define the sonic language that would spread through rock, industrial, dance music, and film over the next decade. This soundtrack gave him a place to connect those worlds without pretending they were the same thing.

“The Perfect Drug” remains the center of gravity. It is restless, dense, overclocked, and almost too complicated to imagine as a conventional single. The track’s reputation as a live rarity only adds to its mystique, but its larger role here matters more: it turns the soundtrack from a Lynch collectible into a real 1997 rock artifact.

Reznor’s fingerprints also run through “Videodrones; Questions,” recorded with Peter Christopherson, and the closing “Driver Down.” These are not palate cleansers. They are connective tissue, making the record feel less like a playlist and more like a broadcast intercepted from a different reality.

The Strange Beauty Of The Seams

A soundtrack can be more than an album, but that also means it can be less satisfying as an album.

That tension drives our whole conversation. The sequencing is bold, but it is not always smooth. Barry Adamson’s pieces, including “Mr. Eddy’s Theme 1,” “Mr. Eddy’s Theme 2,” “Something Wicked This Way Comes,” and “Hollywood Sunset,” add character and period detail. Yet their thin, sometimes dry production can pull a listener out of the thick industrial-noir atmosphere established by Bowie, Reznor, and Badalamenti.

The heavier turns can also arrive with startling force. “Rammstein” and “Heirate Mich” do not ease their way into the record. They kick open a door. That is probably the point, especially if you know the film’s escalation, but it exposes the difference between a soundtrack designed to intensify scenes and an album designed for repeat listening in a car, headphones, or a late-night room.

There is a compelling argument that Lost Highway should have been two discs: one for the songs and one for the score. Put Bowie, Nine Inch Nails, the Pumpkins, Reed, Marilyn Manson, Rammstein, and Jobim in one sequence. Let Badalamenti and Adamson occupy another. But separating them might also erase the album’s central weirdness. The friction is not a flaw that can be fully edited away. It is the record’s identity.

A Perfect 1997 Time Capsule

This album could only have happened in 1997.

The mix is too particular to its moment. Bowie was in the industrial-art-rock phase that had produced Outside. The Pumpkins were navigating the aftermath ofMellon Collie and the Infinite Sadnessand moving toward the electronic and piano-driven territory ofAdore. Reznor was between the massive shadow ofThe Downward Spiraland the long, difficult path towardThe Fragile. Rammstein had not yet broken widely in the United States, but the soundtrack gave listeners an early encounter with their controlled, mechanized menace.

Then there is the weirdest left turn of all: Antônio Carlos Jobim and “Insensatez.” On paper, it is absurd to put a bossa nova master between Marilyn Manson and Barry Adamson. In a David Lynch setting, it makes a kind of perfect emotional sense. Beauty becomes disorienting. Familiarity feels suspect. A warm sound can be more unsettling than a distorted guitar when it appears in the wrong room.

That is why the soundtrack still lands. It is not simply a compilation of artists who mattered in the 1990s. It is a snapshot of a cultural moment when industrial, alternative rock, electronic music, and noir cinema were all sharing the same uneasy air.

The Verdict Is In The Friction

Lost Highway works best when you let it remain unresolved.

Is it a great album, or a great set of scenes that never quite wanted to become an album? Does the score strengthen the songs, or interrupt them? Would trimming a Rammstein track, several Barry Adamson cuts, and the less essential detours make this a killer 45-minute record? Or would that neatness destroy what Lynch and Reznor were actually trying to preserve?

The record sold in serious numbers for a soundtrack of its kind and gave listeners a rare meeting point for Bowie devotees, Nine Inch Nails obsessives, Pumpkins fans, industrial heads, and Lynch completists. But popularity is not the same as clarity. The debate is still alive because every listener can build a different version of Lost Highway in their head.

Listen to the episode for our full verdict, then drop a comment: which track holds this soundtrack together, and which one sends you looking for the skip button?

Episode Highlights

• 00:42: The Union runoff, how Lost Highway beat BulletBoys’ Freakshow 62 to 38

• 05:18: David Lynch’s movie world, from Dune and Blue Velvet to Twin Peaks and Lost Highway

• 12:07: Trent Reznor, David Lynch, and the origin story behind the soundtrack

• 20:33: “I’m Deranged,” “The Perfect Drug,” and why the sequencing feels like a noir narrative

• 33:13: The Barry Adamson problem, atmosphere versus interruption

• 34:20: Why score pieces and rock songs can make difficult album companions

• 40:04: Marilyn Manson, late-1990s soundtrack economics, and the CD-era single trap

• 44:17: Why Lost Highway is a pure 1997 time capsule

• 47:31: Worthy soundtrack, better EP, or decent single?

Suggest an Album

How Did This Miss?

How did a band with KISS connections, a Capitol deal, and a Top 40 single disappear?

That is the question sitting at the center of Violation. Starz had Bill Aucoin, the manager best known for building KISS into an arena-sized phenomenon, in their corner. They recorded with Jack Douglas, who had already helped define the early sound of Aerosmith. Guitarist Richie Ranno would later play on Gene Simmons’ 1978 solo album. On paper, that sounds like a straight line to something much bigger.

Instead, Starz became one of those bands musicians remember, crate-diggers defend, and casual rock fans somehow never encountered. Their second album reached No. 89 on the Billboard 200, while “Cherry Baby” climbed to No. 33 on the Billboard Hot 100, their biggest single. That is not nothing. But it is also a long way from the level of cultural permanence enjoyed by KISS, Cheap Trick, or the Raspberries.

The story gets stranger because the ingredients are all here. Violation was cut at New York’s Record Plant and A&R Recording, with engineer Jay Messina, then released by Capitol Recordsin 1977. It is polished without becoming sterile, heavy without leaning fully into metal, and pop-minded without abandoning the odd instincts that separate a durable rock record from a stack of forgotten radio singles.

What we hear is a band caught in the productive friction between accessibility and ambition. Starz could write a chorus that felt built for FM radio. They just could not always resist making it stranger.

Subscribe now

The Hooks Have Teeth

“Cherry Baby” makes a very persuasive opening argument.

The song has the kind of chorus that feels instantly familiar, as if it had always been tucked between “Surrender” and “Come On Feel the Noize” on a late-night rock-radio playlist. Its peak at No. 33 makes sense. The hook is immediate, bright, and almost bubblegum in its simplicity, yet the rest of the arrangement is tougher and more restless than the chorus initially suggests.

That tension runs through the best parts of Violation. “Rock Six Times,” “Sing It, Shout It,” and the title track follow the same basic mission: make hard rock that is catchy enough to sing after one pass, then complicate the route there. “Sing It, Shout It,” written with Sean Delaney and Jon Parrot, is especially revealing. The chorus carries a KISS-sized command, but the verses take higher, more theatrical melodic turns than that comparison would imply.

If you love the pop instincts of Cheap Trick, the crunch of KISS, and the melodic audacity of Styx, this is the zone where Starz earns its reputation. The songs are not simply built around a riff and a slogan. They contain overlapping guitar lines, unexpected vocal peaks, and arrangements that keep shifting once you think you have them mapped out.

That may also be part of the commercial problem. KISS often made the obvious choice feel inevitable. Starz frequently makes the more interesting choice, and interesting is not always the same as instantly legible. Violation asks you to stay with it past the first hook.

Heavy Without the Wall

The heaviness on Violation comes from the rhythm section, not from a blanket of distortion.

That matters. The album’s guitars are often clean to lightly overdriven, leaving space for Richie Ranno and Brendan Harkin to stack melodic parts rather than simply bulldoze the mix. The bass is loud, active, and occasionally fuzzed into something genuinely nasty. It gives “S.T.E.A.D.Y.” and “Subway Terror” their weight without sacrificing the clarity of the playing.

It is a very 1977 kind of production choice, and Jack Douglas knew how to make it work. Listen to early Aerosmith or the classic AC/DC records: the guitars are not always saturated, but the band feels huge because you can hear the strings, the pick attack, the bass movement, and the drummer pushing behind the beat. Violation lives in that same open-air mix.

“S.T.E.A.D.Y.” is one of the record’s best examples of Starz refusing to settle. It begins in a slower, heavier mode, then pivots toward an unexpectedly buoyant chorus. The song pulls downward with the riff and then keeps trying to lift itself free. “Subway Terror” is rougher and more direct, but it has its own weird, skewed momentum. Both tracks show a band more interested in movement than in simply repeating a successful formula.

That is why the album can sound more sophisticated than some of the groups it is routinely compared with. The music may share DNA with KISS, Angel, and power-pop contemporaries, but the internal logic is more complicated. Starz wants the hook. They also want the detour.

The Back Half Problem

Violation is strongest when it is either fully sweet or fully strange.

The opening run is formidable: “Cherry Baby,” “Rock Six Times,” “Sing It, Shout It,” and “Violation” make a convincing case for Starz as overlooked late-1970s melodic hard rock. The original nine-song LP is only 36 minutes long, so there is little room for filler. Yet the second side occasionally settles into a more generic boogie-rock lane, especially on “All Night Long” and “Cool One.”

Those songs are not disasters. They simply do not generate the same friction. They feel closer to familiar early- to mid-1970s rock language, where a good groove and an easy chorus can carry the day. Starz is more compelling when its writing gets less comfortable, when the band lets the singer climb, the bass growl, or the guitars lean into their off-kilter melodic chemistry.

That makes the album’s closing track, “Is That a Street Light or the Moon?,” such a fascinating problem. It is theatrical, high-voiced, and almost Broadway-adjacent in spots. It does not sound like the predictable pre-power-ballad move a band of this era might have made. Instead, it feels like Starz trying on a different identity in public.

Does it fit? Not neatly. Is it memorable? Absolutely.

This is the contradiction that makes Violation worth returning to. We can imagine a tighter, more commercially ruthless record with nine “Cherry Baby”-level choruses. We can also imagine a bolder album that goes all-in on “S.T.E.A.D.Y.” and the closing track’s dramatic weirdness. Starz gives us both impulses, sometimes in the same song.

Subscribe now

The Band That Could Not Decide

Starz had the sound. What they lacked was a single, unmistakable identity.

That may sound harsh, but it explains a lot. KISS had the makeup, the mythology, and an instantly recognizable visual language. Cheap Trick had the oddball cool of Rick Nielsen, the beautiful-people-versus-misfits tension, and the songs to make all of it stick. Starz had a sharp logo, a major-label platform, a manager who understood presentation, and a set of musicians capable of delivering serious melodic hard rock.

But what exactly were they selling?

A future-dystopia concept involving forbidden rock and teenage rebellion? A glossy power-pop band with hard-rock guitars? A proto-glam influence? A smart, musician-friendly band working just outside the center of the mainstream? The answer is all of the above, which is artistically more interesting than a neat brand strategy but commercially confusing.

That is not just hindsight. The album’s reception has always seemed divided between listeners who hear the melodic craft and listeners who hear cheese. AllMusic describes Starz’s approach as sleek, commercial hard rock that pointed toward what would later be called pop-metal. That feels right, but it also underlines the timing issue. Violation arrived before the 1980s market fully rewarded this exact blend of big vocals, polished production, and hard-rock punch.

The future musicians who praised Starz were probably responding to those little glints of possibility. Not necessarily a wholesale blueprint, but a set of signals: the melodic reach, the punchy bass, the willingness to put something weird inside a catchy rock song.

Our Verdict

Violation is the kind of record that makes the Dig Me Out case for itself.

The record has flaws. It can lose focus on the back half. Its identity is fragmented. “Cherry Baby” may set expectations for a more consistent rush of sugar than the rest of the record delivers. But the best songs have real staying power, and the playing rewards the kind of attention that these albums rarely got in their original moment.

The external case is stronger than you might expect. “Cherry Baby” was a genuine Top 40 hit, the album charted, and the group’s KISS-adjacent history is well documented. Yet the stronger argument is in the listening: this is a smart, strange, melodic hard-rock record from a band that should be much easier to place in rock history than it is.

Was Violation an overlooked classic, a great half-record, or an album that works better as a tightly sequenced EP? Is “Cherry Baby” the accessible entry point or a misleading promise? Does “Is That a Street Light or the Moon?” close the album brilliantly, or does it wander in from another record entirely?

Listen to the full episode for our final verdict, then drop your own take in the comments. Which Starz song gets its hooks into you, and which one leaves you cold?

Episode Highlights

• 00:44: The September poll, how Violation beat Wishbone Ash, 1994, and Rose Tattoo

• 02:26: The KISS connection, Bill Aucoin, Richie Ranno, and Gene Simmons

• 07:23: Starz’s origin story, Capitol Records, Jack Douglas, and “Cherry Baby”

• 11:37: Why musicians championed Starz even when the public largely did not

• 16:44: “Sing It, Shout It,” “S.T.E.A.D.Y.,” and the sophisticated melodic twists

• 22:14: Michael Lee Smith, Rex Smith, and the album’s theatrical vocal range

• 30:07: “Subway Terror,” “Violation,” and the harder-edged side of the record

• 32:41: “Is That a Street Light or the Moon?,” the strange closing track

• 38:40: Why Violation may have been buried by timing, promotion, and unclear identity

• 44:30: What does not work, from “Cool One” to the album’s inconsistent second half

• 56:22: Final verdicts, worthy album versus better EP

Suggest an Album

The 1998 Album That Refused to Pick a Personality

What if the problem is that Split Personalities has too many good ideas?

When 12 Rods released Split Personalities in 1998, alternative rock was supposed to be getting simpler. Radio had room for polished post-grunge, pop-punk hooks, nu-metal heaviness, and the last big commercial turns from the first wave of 90s alternative. Then came this band, originally from Oxford, Ohio and transplanted to Minneapolis, with a record that kept refusing the obvious answer.

This was not a record interested in delivering one clean, sellable version of itself. It could sound like melodic power pop for a minute, then detour into drum-and-bass rhythms, synthetic textures, loungey passages, fuzzed-out guitar, and something that feels almost like art-rock prog without the cape-and-Mellotron baggage. It is catchy in pieces, weird in pieces, and often both at once.

The record was released by V2 Records, the label founded by Richard Branson after his departure from Virgin, and it earned a remarkable 9.7 from Pitchfork. That score is part of the mythology now, especially because Split Personalities does not feel like the kind of record built for easy consensus. Pitchfork later described the band’s early work as balancing “spacy, synth-driven lounge jazz” with “sharp-toothed arena-pop.”

That tension is exactly why it still works. Or, at least, why it keeps demanding another listen.

Subscribe now

The Band Behind the Contradiction

12 Rods had already established themselves as a band with a difficult-to-categorize center of gravity. The group formed in Ohio before moving to Minneapolis, with Ryan Olcott as its central songwriter and constant presence. AllMusic describes them as a post-new-wave unit, while their later history shows just how much the band’s identity remained tied to Olcott.

On Split Personalities, Olcott handles vocals, guitar, synthesizer, and bass, while Eve Olcott contributes synthesizers, guitar, and vocals. Christopher McGuire’s drumming becomes one of the record’s defining voices, and it is the thing that finally made the album click most clearly for us. The rhythm section does not merely hold the songs together. It constantly changes the songs’ temperature.

This is the first 12 Rods album we have covered in 2026 after revisiting Lost Time, the 2002 album produced by Todd Rundgren. The two records share DNA, especially the fearless collision of melody and complication, but Split Personalities feels more restless. It feels like a band testing every door in the room before deciding which one to walk through.

That can be exhilarating. It can also make the album feel like it is still deciding what it wants to become.

The title is not subtle, but it is accurate. Almost every song has its own split personality.

Drums Make the Record Move

The biggest revelation here is McGuire’s playing. The drums make this album feel alive even when the arrangements are packed with overdubs, electronics, and sudden stylistic pivots.

Take “Chromatically Declining Me.” The song locks synth rhythm and acoustic drums together until it develops a galloping, nearly techno feel. Then the tom work takes over in a way that feels physical and performative, pulling the track out of its machine-like pattern and into something stranger. It is not just a clever arrangement. It sounds like a real band taking risks in real time.

That same dynamic tension runs through the record. The drums can support down-strummed, distorted guitar passages without losing their snap. They can pull a song toward a lighter, almost jazzy or lounge-like space. They can make a mid-tempo groove feel like it has hidden trapdoors underneath it.

We kept coming back to how unusually good the drum sound is, too. It is roomy but punchy, natural but forceful. The opening fill on “Make Out Music” jumps out with the kind of immediacy that makes you want to rewind just to hear the sound of the room again.

This is where Split Personalities earns some of its reputation. Beneath the surface-level weirdness is a band that understands arrangement, texture, and dynamics at a high level. The record may feel scattered, but it is rarely careless.

Power Pop With Its Wires Exposed

There is a power-pop record inside Split Personalities. You can hear it in “The Stupidest Boy,” in the melodic instincts throughout “Split Personality,” and in the way certain chorus fragments threaten to become massive. The album’s ten-song, 51-minute track list makes clear that 12 Rods were not afraid of giving those ideas room to stretch.

But this is where the record gets complicated.

12 Rods regularly set us up to expect direct, three-and-a-half-minute melodic payoffs, then refuse to give them. Instead of simplifying a hook, they veer into a new keyboard sound, an unexpected guitar texture, an awkwardly fascinating vocal delivery, or a longer instrumental section. You can hear echoes of Brian Wilson in the melodic sensibility, a little Procol Harum in the organ colors, flashes of Faith No More in the keyboard mood shifts, and an art-rock nerve that recalls Brainiac.

That is a lot of information for one band to process. It is also the point.

At their best, 12 Rods sound like they are rebuilding familiar rock language out of unfamiliar materials. The hooks are there, but they are bent. The choruses are there, but they may not arrive where you expect them. The pop instincts are there, but the band keeps challenging itself to move past the obvious resolution.

This is not music that rewards passive listening. Put it on while doing something else and you may wonder whether your playlist jumped albums. Sit with it and the logic starts to reveal itself.

Ryan Olcott’s voice is the album’s sharpest dividing line.

There are moments when it works beautifully. When he leans into a breathier approach, the singing gets intimate and vulnerable. When he opens up and belts, the record gains a necessary sense of release. On quieter material like “I Wish You Were a Girl,” there is an emo-adjacent fragility that keeps the song from drifting completely into novelty.

But the record also leans hard on high-register theatricality, robotic cadences, repetition, and vocal choices that can feel deliberately abrasive. Sometimes that is a productive tension. Sometimes it feels like the voice is competing with the music rather than riding inside it.

The problem is not a lack of ability. The voice has range, personality, and flexibility. The issue is that Split Personalities often asks it to be one more eccentric texture in an arrangement already full of eccentric textures. When everything is trying to be distinctive, the vocal can become the thing that tips the song from adventurous into exhausting.

That is why the album produces such different reactions. If you hear those choices as a band pushing past conventional indie rock, the record becomes thrilling. If you hear them as affectation standing between you and the hook, the record can feel longer than its 51-minute runtime. Apple Music lists the album at ten tracks and just over 51 minutes, including “Split Personality,” “Red,” “I Am Faster,” “Chromatically Declining Me,” and “Part of 2.”

That friction is built into the record.

Subscribe now

A Great Album That Needs an Editor

The main criticism we kept circling was not that 12 Rods needed fewer ideas. It is that they may have needed more editing.

“I Am Faster” is the clearest example. Its slow, heavy build has real atmosphere, with a sense of weight that brings Failure to mind. But the song spends so much time approaching its destination that it risks making the listener wait for a version of the track that is already inside it. Start it closer to the quiet vocal section, cut some of the scene-setting noise, and the impact could be even greater.

The same goes for some of the false starts, repeated intros, and extended passages scattered across the album. Those choices are very 90s, when bands often treated extra time at the beginning of a song as proof of mood, seriousness, or texture. But a few trims could have made this record hit harder.

That is the central what-if of Split Personalities. Should 12 Rods have tightened these songs into concise, strange power-pop singles? Or should they have pushed further into the prog and art-rock side, making the weirdness even less apologetic?

Instead, the album lives right in the middle. That can be frustrating. It can also be uniquely compelling.

Few bands make music that sounds this smart, this catchy, this awkward, this technically assured, and this allergic to playing it safe.

The Verdict Is Split Too

Split Personalities is a record for listeners who can enjoy a hook with a crooked smile. Its fans hear an undervalued late-90s masterwork, and that Pitchfork 9.7 certainly helped cement the legend. Wikipedia and Discogs both document the 1998 release and its still-discussed critical reputation.

We hear the appeal. The drumming is exceptional. The arrangements are daring. The electronic and organic elements often lock into something nobody else was making in quite the same way. This is a band with real musical intelligence, not just a stack of influences.

But the flaws are hard to ignore, too. Some songs go on too long. The vocal mannerisms can wear down their welcome. The record occasionally feels caught between two excellent versions of itself: a tightly wound oddball pop album and a sprawling art-rock statement.

So here are the questions we keep coming back to:

• Is this a power-pop album that needed more hooks, or an art-rock album that needed to get weirder?

• Which 12 Rods personality do you prefer: the strange melodic pop band or the restless experimental band?

• Do the vocals make the record more distinctive, or do they keep you at arm’s length?

• Which song is the best case for Split Personalities as a lost 90s classic?

Listen to the full episode for where we ultimately land, then drop a comment with your own verdict. This is exactly the kind of record that gets more interesting when people argue about it.

Episode Highlights

• 00:44: The poll ballot, Green River, 12 Rods, Josh Rouse, and Skid Row enter a close community race

• 05:42: The 12 Rods story so far, Oxford, Ohio roots, Minneapolis relocation, and Ryan Olcott’s long-running project

• 08:24: Split Personalities arrives, its V2 Records release and Pitchfork’s 9.7 score

• 10:24: “Chromatically Declining Me,” how synth pulse and live tom work create the album’s most unusual groove

• 16:52: “Make Out Music,” why the drum sound becomes a major part of the album’s appeal

• 19:23: “The Stupidest Boy,” power-pop instincts colliding with genre-hopping arrangements

• 24:30: “I Wish You Were a Girl,” slowcore, emo, and the record’s quieter emotional side

• 30:49: The difficulty of a power-pop album that declines to deliver conventional big hooks

• 35:31: The vocal debate, theatricality, robotic phrasing, and the line between distinctive and grating

• 40:28: “I Am Faster,” false intros, long songs, and the case for a tighter edit

• 44:21: Final verdicts, a worthy album for one of us and a better EP for the other

• 50:58: Why 12 Rods remain such a hard band to categorize

So we’re going to overtime to decide which 90s album deserves a deep dive podcast.

Freakshow is a band mid-fall , sensing the ground shifting beneath them, pivoting hard and making something rawer and stranger than anything they’d done before. Lost Highway is David Lynch assembling the decade’s darkest sonic voices into something that felt like a transmission from the underside of the whole era.

The 24-hour runoff is live now

🤘 Bulletboys — Freakshow (1991) — A California metal band swinging hard into post-grunge territory, trying to survive the shift, and making one of the more interesting albums of the transition era

🎬 Various Artists — Lost Highway (1997) — David Lynch’s fever dream of a soundtrack, featuring Nine Inch Nails, David Bowie, Marilyn Manson, and Smashing Pumpkins woven around Angelo Badalamenti’s score

Poi Dog Pondering pulled 15% of the vote and Monster Voodoo Machine closed out at 5% — both going back to the suggestion pool for a future ballot.

This one is yours to settle.

What’s your gut? Did the right two albums make it to the runoff — or did this ballot rob somebody? Drop it in the comments.

Ed Buller Mixed It. Hollywood Records Released It. Then Tinfed Vanished.

J Dziak and Tim Minneci · September 22, 2026

A Sacramento band fusing alt-rock muscle with electronic shadows, a Britpop producer behind the board, and a Disney-backed major label releasing the whole thing in 2000. Tinfed‘s Tried + True was Board of Directors member Chris Martz’s pick, the community voted it a Worthy Album, and the hosts landed somewhere a little more selective. Come hear the argument.

Listen now

From Chicago Folk-Pop to Canadian Industrial Metal: The September 90s Ballot Is Wild

Poi Dog Pondering, Bulletboys’ Freakshow, the Lost Highway soundtrack, and Monster Voodoo Machine walk into a poll. One of them becomes a full episode.

Vote now

Know a lost or forgotten album that deserves the spotlight? Suggest it for a future episode.

Coming Up Next

12 Rods – Split Personalities (Tuesday, September 29)

Minneapolis art-rockers who sounded like nobody else on V2 in 1998: falsetto hooks, synth squiggles, and prog ambition crammed into pop songs. The community voted for this one.

Then on October 6, the community’s 70s pick: Starz Violation (1977).

Give Split Personalities a spin before Tuesday and come ready with your take.

New Releases

Beck – Ride Lonesome

Think back to 2002, Sea Change on the stereo, the guy who gave you “Loser” suddenly singing “Lost Cause” like he’d been awake for three days. That record rewired what people thought Beck was. Ride Lonesome is his first album in seven years, and it reunites the Sea Change and Morning Phase band with Nigel Godrich and Beck’s father David Campbell on orchestrations, closing what critics now call a heartache trilogy written in the wake of his divorce.

What works: Alexis Petridis at The Guardian calls it a stunning end to the trilogy, where “everything here … is melodically exquisite.”

What doesn’t: Christopher Anthony at The Fire Note gives it 3.5/5: “The only snag is how polished some of the arrangements become.” If you wanted the Odelay Beck, this is not that Beck.

Neil Young and the Chrome Hearts – Second Song

Picture 1972, Harvest on the turntable, “Heart of Gold” drifting out of every open car window that summer. Neil Young has been chasing and running from that sound ever since. On Second Song, the 80-year-old goes back even further: two of its seven tracks, “I’ll Love You Forever” and “Casting Me Away From You,” date to his teenage Squires days in the mid-60s, recut with Micah Nelson, Spooner Oldham, and the rest of the Chrome Hearts.

What works: MOJO calls it a late-career classic and “comfortably his best since the molten sprawl of 2012’s Psychedelic Pill.”

What doesn’t: Alexis Petridis at The Guardian finds it shaky in stretches: “Day After Day’s seven minutes feel like seven months.” Patience with late-period Neil is still required.

Anthrax – Cursum Perficio

Among the Living is in your Walkman, Scott Ian’s shorts are on MTV, and “Indians” is the mosh call at every basement show in your zip code. The Big Four’s New York wildcards have now gone a full decade since 2016’s For All Kings, and they came back with a Latin title meaning “my journey ends here” plus “The Long Goodbye,” a song about Ian’s father’s battle with Alzheimer’s.

What works: Essi Berelian at Louder: “The variety is hugely impressive, the delivery a hundred per cent on-point.”

What doesn’t: Jeremy Wolfers at Sputnikmusic rates it 3.0 and flags “stubborn repetitiveness and bloated song lengths,” though he calls “It’s For the Kids” the clear standout.

Want to hand-pick an album and join us on the show to dig into it? That’s what the Board of Directors is for. Join at dmounion.com.

Soft Cell – Danceteria

That “Tainted Love” synth blip, the two-note “bink bink,” Marc Almond’s voice curling around every syllable like cigarette smoke in a Soho club. Danceteria is Soft Cell’s sixth and final album, named for the Manhattan club where Almond and Dave Ball spent their early-80s nights. Ball finished work on it just before he died in October 2025, and Nona Hendryx of Labelle guests on the closing cover of Was (Not Was)’s “Out Come the Freaks.”

What works: John Murphy at musicOMH gives it 4/5 and calls it “a lovely swansong to the late Dave Ball.”

What doesn’t: The Scotsman goes two stars, calling it “overlong and underwhelming” and the title track “a poor man’s Pet Shop Boys.” Come for the goodbye, not a second Non-Stop Erotic Cabaret.

Europe – Come This Madness

You can hear it right now: the keyboard fanfare of “The Final Countdown,” 1986, the song that soundtracked every high school pep rally for a decade. The Swedes have spent twenty years quietly making heavier, bluesier records nobody expected. Come This Madness is their first since 2017’s Walk the Earth, produced by Tom Dalgety (Ghost, Rammstein, Opeth), and it leans into the darker, harder side of the band.

What works: David Randall at Get Ready to ROCK!: “Europe are back and firing on all five cylinders.”

What doesn’t: Klaus Saalfeld at Hellfire Magazin gives it 6.5/10, writing that the record fails to inspire “restlose Begeisterung” (total enthusiasm). If you only want the synth-horn Europe, it isn’t here.

Godflesh – Decay

1989, Birmingham. Streetcleaner drops and a drum machine suddenly sounds heavier than any drummer alive, a blueprint half of 90s industrial metal would borrow. Decay is the duo’s tenth album and, by their own plan, their second to last, built from the Purge sessions with Justin Broadrick delivering fewer than 150 words over 42 minutes.

What works: Blake Michelle at Boolin Tunes rates it 8/10 and says opener “Master and Slave” “might be the best song Godflesh have ever made.”

What doesn’t: The same Boolin Tunes review bristles at closer “Consume Me”: “this droning, uninteresting loop refuses to go away.” If you never got on the Godflesh train, the drone-heavy stretches won’t be your ticket.

Also Out This Week

Tom Morello – Everyone Gets Everything They Want: The Rage guitarist steps up as rock frontman with Serj Tankian, Kneecap, and Beartooth along for the ride. Riff Magazine gives it 8/10 but admits “it can feel all over the place.”

Roger Taylor – Violence Insane in a Beautiful World: Queen’s drummer and the “Radio Ga Ga” writer turns in his seventh solo record, an eco-political album SPIN frames as “both a warning and an expression of wonder.”

onelinedrawing – RAINBOWMACHINE: Far’s Jonah Matranga makes a full-band rock record with producer Jay Maas. New Noise gives it 4.5/5 and calls it “undoubtedly masterful.”

Stryper – Throne of Thorns: The yellow-and-black attack’s 18th studio album, which Heavy Music HQ says “stands proudly among their best.”

Bonnie “Prince” Billy – Ghosts of American Psychonauts: Will Oldham’s live set from LA’s Pico Union Project, with three saxophones reshaping The Purple Bird songs. KLOF Mag calls it a compelling addition to his catalog.

The Wolfgang Press – Asylum Variations: The 4AD post-punk originals’ second reunion album, recorded straight to ADAT tape. Tinnitist named it an Album of the Week.

Paul Laine – The Long Road Back: The Danger Danger singer’s first solo record in over 30 years. The Rock Pit goes 9.5/10: “right now it’s the one the rest have to beat.”

Gary Barden – Empowered Emotions: The early Michael Schenker Group voice, with Schenker and Don Airey guesting. Fireworks calls it “a cohesive, melodic, and powerful statement.”

Lacrimas Profundere – Lay Me Down O Silent Fear: German gothic metal veterans pushing further into metalcore. Blabbermouth lands at 6/10.

Fresh in the Hopper

These are recent listener suggestions sitting in the queue, waiting for their moment.

Groovezilla, Groovezilla (1994), submitted by Chip. A Kentucky band Chip caught every chance he got at Stache’s in Columbus from ‘92 to ‘95, somewhere between Bad Brains and the Royal Crescent Mob. It isn’t on streaming, which is exactly why it belongs here.

Damien, Every Dog Has Its Day (1987), submitted by Jeff. Jeff calls them possibly the most underrated band ever out of Ohio: heavier than mainstream 80s metal, more melodic than thrash, sitting right in the US power metal pocket.

The Kings, The Kings Are Here (1980), submitted by Mike Androff. You know “This Beat Goes On / Switchin’ to Glide.” Mike says the other eight songs on this under-31-minute record are worth digging out too, starting with a guitarist named Mister Zero.

Lock Up, Something Bitchin’ This Way Comes (1989), submitted by Gavin Reid. Late-80s funky hair metal with a pre-Rage Tom Morello on guitar, which makes it a very tidy companion to Morello’s new record this week.

Got a lost or forgotten album that deserves the spotlight? Drop it in the Hopper.

What are you listening to this week? And if this roundup saved you some digging, consider subscribing to support the mission.

Subscribe now

Join the Board of Directors at dmounion.com.

Subscribe now

The Future Was Almost Here

What if the missing 2000 alt-rock hit was hiding on a Disney-backed label?

By August 2000, alternative rock had splintered into a thousand possible futures. Britpop melancholy was still hanging in the air. Industrial rock had filtered into the mainstream. Electronic beats were no longer exotic in a guitar band. Everybody wanted the next mutation, the sound that could carry the weirdness of the late 90s into a new decade.

Tinfed had a version of that sound on Tried + True, their third and final studio album, released August 22, 2000 through Hollywood Records. The Sacramento band had already traveled through the indie-label world with Synaptic Hardware and Hypersonic Hyperphonic before landing in a strange major-label orbit through Third Rail and Hollywood. Wikipedia confirms that this was their final studio record, which makes its reach for a bigger, more futuristic sound feel a little bittersweet in retrospect.

This is not a lost masterpiece simply because it failed to become one. It is more interesting than that. Tried + True sounds like a band arriving at a compelling identity, then occasionally wandering away from it before the song is over.

The record lives in that tension. When it finds its balance, it has a sleek, moody, almost cinematic pull. When it overcorrects toward programmed beats and electronic atmosphere, it can feel like it has mistaken the frosting for the cake.

Still, the best moments make a strong case for keeping this record in the conversation.

Hollywood’s Oddest Rock Bet

Hollywood Records was never an obvious home for a band like Tinfed.

The label had the resources of Disney behind it, but its catalog often felt like a wildly uneven aisle in an old record store: Queen, soundtrack releases, Los Lobos, Fishbone, Fastball, and plenty of artists who could not have had much in common beyond a shared logo on the back cover. That mismatch becomes part of Tried + True’s strange charm. It is a real major-label release from an era when “major label” still meant something, yet it feels like the kind of record you might discover in a used bin with no memory of ever seeing it advertised.

Tinfed had a more direct brush with the cultural machinery of 2000, too. “Immune” appeared on the Mission: Impossible 2 soundtrack, putting the band near one of the year’s biggest blockbuster franchises, even if that placement did not translate into lasting visibility for the group.

The album’s own sleeve and aesthetic suggest a mid-century vision of tomorrow, the kind of sleek science-fiction design language that makes the music’s electronics feel intentional rather than ornamental. That is the important distinction here. Tinfed were not trying to become Nine Inch Nails, and they were not building a full-on industrial machine. They were making melodic alternative rock with digital shadows around its edges.

That lane had room to grow. The question is whether the songs could consistently carry it.

Subscribe now

Sci-Fi Pop With a Human Voice

The strongest idea on Tried + True is the sound we kept calling sci-fi pop.

The guitars are present but rarely dominate. Bass lines ground the songs. Drums often feel performed rather than simply programmed, but they are treated, doubled, and surrounded by electronic texture until the grooves feel slightly displaced from ordinary alt-rock. Keyboards flicker in and out. Acoustic layers can suddenly widen into electric choruses. A staccato guitar part might show up just long enough to change the song’s temperature.

That is the record’s best trick. Tinfed build a futuristic mood without disappearing into pure electronic music.

The opening stretch makes the case. “Way Thru,” “Immune,” and “Drop” create a three-song run that feels focused, concise, and alert to detail. A slight harmonic or synth-bass shift in “Immune” is enough to make its second verse feel different from the first. It is not a giant reinvention, but it signals that somebody in the room was thinking about movement, contrast, and the small sonic adjustments that keep a mid-tempo song from flattening out.

The vocal is the other crucial element. Ray Osborne’s delivery can be breathy, rhythmic, intimate, or suddenly more forceful in a chorus. He drops into falsetto without turning it into a gimmick. At points, there is a little of Myles Kennedy’s dramatic reach, though not that full-on powerhouse force. Elsewhere, the phrasing can feel closer to Stephen Malkmus, especially in its almost-spoken looseness.

It is an unusual instrument, and it gives Tinfed an identity their name never quite does.

When the Mix Gets in the Way

The frustrating part is that Tried + True often knows what it wants to be, but not always how to present it.

There are moments where the production feels muddy or uneven, especially when a song swells into a bigger section. You can hear guitars, electronics, drums, and vocal parts pushing toward a payoff, but the mix does not always let you understand what each element is doing. “Immune” is a good example. The chorus has the outline of a hook, yet the vocal can feel buried right when it needs to come forward and make the case.

More doubling. A clearer harmony. A slightly different vocal treatment. Any of those changes might have taken an already good song closer to the kind of radio-sized payoff the album seems to be chasing.

That makes the record feel less like a songwriting failure than an execution problem. There is real material here. “Drop” has a patient mid-tempo groove and a strong setting for the vocal, even if the repeated lyric starts to test its welcome. “Mouth As Sharp” works because its acoustic layers, drum groove, and expressive vocal all serve the same mood. “Danger Girl” and “It’s Late” understand the album’s core formula: simplify the band arrangement, create a textured bed, and let the singer carry the emotional charge.

When Tinfed follow that formula, the record has a dark, sleek pull that still sounds distinctive.

The Electronic Detour

Tinfed become less convincing when the electronic tools stop supporting the song and start competing with it.

“Never Was Sure” veers toward a trip-hop-adjacent mood, while “Halo” reaches for a fuzzier industrial weight. “Idol” pushes its digital elements even harder. None of these songs are disasters, and “Halo” in particular has a chorus with real appeal, driven by big drum hits and simple ascending and descending guitar movement. But the middle of the album is where the record starts to lose its center.

The problem is not that electronic music and rock should stay in separate rooms. By 2000, bands like Garbage had already proven how naturally guitar rock, programmed beats, and studio manipulation could coexist. The Smashing Pumpkins had also pushed hard into a more synthetic direction on Adore. Tinfed were not behind the curve for trying.

They just sound strongest when rock remains the foundation and electronics provide the strange light around the edges.

There is a difference between using a digital rhythm to complicate a groove and letting the digital rhythm become the entire song’s personality. On the weaker detours, the sound sometimes drifts toward second-tier industrial rock, closer to a less memorable God Lives Underwater B-side than a fully realized Tinfed statement.

That does not erase the ambition. In some ways, it makes the album more revealing. Tinfed were testing every door available to an alternative band at the turn of the millennium. They just did not always know which door led to their own room.

Subscribe now

A Band One Album Away?

Tried + True feels like a record from a band that might have been one album away.

Not one song away, necessarily. There are enough good songs here to build a persuasive alternate version of the record. But one more cycle, one more chance to refine the hooks, tighten the arrangements, and decide exactly how much electronic experimentation served the band’s identity could have made a real difference.

The community heard more than potential. Our listeners voted it a Worthy Album, while we landed on a more selective verdict. That split makes perfect sense. This is exactly the kind of record that rewards a listener willing to meet it halfway. Its flaws are audible, but so is its personality.

Would a clearer mix have turned “Immune” into the breakthrough song? Could “Way Thru,” “Drop,” and “It’s Late” have found an audience if the band had been marketed less like another oddity on Hollywood’s roster? What does a better, tighter version of this album sound like? And does the messiness become part of why it sticks with you?

Listen to the full episode for our final verdict, then drop a comment with your own Tinfed ranking. Are you with the community, or are you building the shorter, sharper version of Tried + True in your head?

Episode Highlights

• 03:06: Tinfed and Tried + True, Chris’s latest community pick lands in our inbox

• 05:30: Hollywood Records, why Tinfed’s major-label home was such a weird fit

• 12:28: “Sci-fi pop,” the layered sound that makes the record feel like early-2000s future rock

• 16:02: “Way Thru,” “Immune,” and “Drop,” the album’s strongest opening run

• 22:04: Production problems, muddy mixes and hooks that need one more push

• 23:42: “Halo,” “Never Was Sure,” and the electronic middle stretch

• 31:39: Ed Buller, Britpop connections, and the mystery behind Tinfed’s drum treatments

• 36:38: Final verdict

We’ve got Poi Dog Pondering chasing something warm, restless, and big-hearted. Bulletboys trying to turn a freak show into an arena-sized event. David Lynch’s Lost Highway soundtrack lurking in the shadows with a trunk full of dread. And Monster Voodoo Machine bringing the Canadian industrial-metal grime.

There is no safe pick here. That is exactly why the 90s were so fun.

These are the four listener-suggested albums on the September 2026 ’90s ballot. One of them will become a full Dig Me Out episode, complete with the record’s story, our review, host ratings, community ratings, and the arguments that got it there.

The nominees

Poi Dog Pondering — Wishing Like a Mountain and Thinking Like the Sea

Keith P. Miller brought us this one, and it feels like the kind of album that could have become a lifelong companion for the right person at exactly the right moment. Poi Dog Pondering had already traveled a strange, singular path through folk, jazz, pop, and dance music by the time this record arrived. So: is this a lost ’90s gem that deserves a closer listen, or one of those ambitious records that slipped between every available crack?

Bulletboys — Freakshow

Aaron Yoder nominated the Bulletboys’ 1991 follow-up—the record where the Sunset Strip flash got louder, stranger, and a little more unruly. Freakshow arrived as the ground was shifting beneath hard rock, when glam’s old rules were about to get rewritten in permanent marker. Does it deserve to be remembered as more than a last blast from a changing era? Or is it precisely the kind of messy, confusing album Dig Me Out was built to revisit?

Various Artists — Lost Highway

Jon PENNYCOOK threw the soundtrack grenade onto the ballot. Lost Highway is not just a collection of songs attached to a movie; it’s a mood trap. David Bowie, Nine Inch Nails, Marilyn Manson, Rammstein, Smashing Pumpkins, Barry Adamson—the whole thing moves like fluorescent light through a motel window at 3 a.m. If you want an episode where the album conversation turns into a conversation about film, dread, ’90s alternative culture, and the art of the soundtrack, this is your pick.

Monster Voodoo Machine — Suffersystem

Kyle nominated this 1994 slab of Canadian industrial metal, a record with enough grease under its fingernails to make the rest of the ballot nervous. Monster Voodoo Machine lived in that zone where hard rock, industrial, groove metal, and full-on menace kept bleeding into each other. The question is not whether Suffersystem is polished. The question is whether it hits like a record that deserved a bigger, louder afterlife.

Decide what happens next

Make your case

• Which album on this ballot still has something to prove?

• What song from your pick is the one that makes the entire case?

• Did Freakshow get caught in the wrong moment?

• Is Lost Highway one of the great soundtrack rabbit holes of the decade?

• Or is there a Monster Voodoo Machine or Poi Dog Pondering believer out there ready to make the rest of us listen differently?

  ---

  Dig Me Out is a reader-supported publication. To receive new posts and support my work, consider becoming a free or paid subscriber.

In 1985, the center of gravity for American hard rock was pulling hard toward Los Angeles. The visual language was getting louder, the choruses were getting bigger, and labels were figuring out how to sell a band in a single MTV clip. But Holland came from Chicago, and Little Monsters sounds like it.

The album arrived on Atlantic Records, a genuine major-label bet on singer Tom Holland and guitarist Michael Angelo Batio, years before Batio became synonymous with full-speed technical guitar spectacle and the famously multi-necked instruments of Nitro. That contrast is the first surprise. Little Monsters has plenty of shred, but it is not built to make the guitarist the entire event.

Instead, this is a compact, 34-minute album of tight songs, chunky guitars, sharp lead work, and a vocal presence that can carry melody without sanding down the record’s hard-rock edges. The songs rarely stretch past four minutes. No grand power ballad arrives to halt the momentum. Holland gets in, lands the hook or riff, gives Batio room to burn, then gets out before the whole thing turns into a clinic.

That economy makes the album feel less like a leftover from the Sunset Strip and more like an alternate branch of mid-’80s rock. You can hear the pressure of metal in the guitars, but beneath it is an instinct for power pop, Midwestern melody, and songs that want to do more than provide a runway for solos.

The secret weapon is the songwriting

The best parts of Little Monsters do not sound like anyone was chasing the standard 1985 metal formula.

The opening track, “Lovin’ on Time,” immediately points toward something more interesting. Strip away the distorted guitar and the flashy leads, and the core has a melodic discipline closer to Cheap Trick than to the era’s more interchangeable hard-rock acts. That does not make Holland a power-pop band in leather jackets. It means the band understood that a memorable riff only gets you so far without a verse and chorus that can stand on their own.

“Middle of a Dream” is where that balancing act becomes especially clear. Its acoustic-picked opening creates a spacious, almost 12-string feel before the arrangement pivots into heavier chords. Rather than treating soft and heavy as opposite poles, the song lets them work together. The verses breathe. The chorus tightens the screws. It is a small move, but it separates Holland from bands that treated dynamics as simply slowing down for the ballad.

“Gotta Run” works because it occupies the neglected middle ground. It is not a full-speed rocker, and it is not a lighter-waving power ballad. It is moody, mid-tempo, and built on vocal melody, layered guitars, and an arrangement that trusts the band to create tension without simply turning every dial upward.

Then there is “Keep It to Yourself,” another example of Holland’s underlying pop sense. The verse melody is strong enough to suggest what this band could have become with another album or two, especially as the late-’80s hard-rock market began demanding larger, cleaner, more immediate choruses.

This is where the record earns its place in the Dig Me Out universe. It is not a perfect lost classic. It is a record with an identifiable personality, one that keeps surfacing when Holland leans into songwriting rather than genre posture.

If you have a record that never got its rightful second listen, put it in front of the community. The poll is how these overlooked albums get pulled back into the conversation.

Batio shreds, but the songs survive

Michael Angelo Batio is everywhere on this album, yet he rarely overwhelms it.

That is not a small accomplishment. Batio’s later reputation is built on jaw-dropping technique, speed, ambidextrous playing, and visual excess. On Little Monsters, his guitar work is clearly the work of a player with serious technical firepower, but the solos are usually deployed like solos should be: brief bursts of escalation inside songs that already have a reason to exist.

The comparison that kept returning for us was Vinnie Vincent Invasion. Not because Holland sounds exactly like Vinnie Vincent’s band, but because both projects can feel like pop-minded songwriting covered in a metallic finish, with virtuoso guitar playing pushed well forward in the mix. The key difference is restraint. Holland gives Batio room, but the songs do not get swallowed by the demonstration.

“High Life” gives him one of the album’s more obvious opportunities to cut loose, built around a descending hard-rock riff that recalls the kind of muscular metal heard from bands such as Malice. “Basics of the Bullet” brings a shuffle feel and shouted backing vocals into the mix, placing Batio’s sharper lines against a more rhythmic, bar-band-ready foundation.

There is a revealing live clip of “High Life” in the band’s afterlife online: the song itself runs with album-like efficiency, then the spotlight shifts into a much longer guitar showcase. That split may explain the record’s identity. In the studio, the band and producer Max Carl appear to have kept the excess contained. Onstage, Batio could take the leash off.

It was the right instinct for the album. If Little Monsters had become a full-time shred exercise, its strongest melodies would have disappeared under the fretboard fireworks.

One movie scene kept it alive

Holland’s most-streamed song may be familiar to people who never knew the band’s name.

“Wake Up the Neighborhood” became attached to the 1985 dance-comedy film Girls Just Want to Have Fun, featuring Helen Hunt, Sarah Jessica Parker, and Shannen Doherty. In the film, the song scores a classic ’80s disruption: young characters bring a loud rock band’s energy into a more formal setting, while adults look on in stunned disapproval.

That placement explains why the track has a streaming footprint disproportionate to Holland’s broader cultural visibility. It was a soundtrack moment, a memory trigger, and a song many listeners absorbed without tracing it back to Little Monsters.

It is also a useful illustration of the record’s divide. “Wake Up the Neighborhood” is immediate, driving, and built for a movie scene. It has the kind of generic party-rock utility a soundtrack supervisor wants. But it does not reveal the full story of what makes Holland distinctive. It is more representative of the album’s standard hard-rock side than the more curious melodic material on “Lovin’ on Time,” “Middle of a Dream,” “Gotta Run,” or “Keep It to Yourself.”

The track works. It is fun. But if that is the only Holland song you know, you have missed the part of the record that suggests a band with a more individual path available to it.

Chicago was not the Strip

The question is not why Holland lacked talent. The question is why the timing never gave that talent a second chance.

By the middle of the decade, hard rock was increasingly a regional and visual business. Los Angeles had the clubs, labels, managers, industry attention, and constant proximity that could turn a local band into a national story. Chicago had a different set of strengths: musicianship, rock history, and a power-pop sensibility that sits naturally beside the harder material on Little Monsters.

That Midwestern identity may be precisely what makes the album interesting now. Holland did not fully resemble the emerging glam-metal template, but it also was not part of the heavier underground movements building elsewhere. The band sounds like it was caught in the transition, a few years too early for the huge, radio-focused hooks that would soon dominate the market.

It is tempting to imagine the next record. A 1987 or 1988 Holland album, with the songwriting strengths sharpened and the choruses pushed further forward, might have found a larger audience. Enuff Z’Nuff, another Chicago-area act, would eventually find traction by making melodic hooks and Beatlesque instincts impossible to ignore. Holland had pieces of that same equation, even if Little Monsters never quite locks every one of them into place.

The band’s short life makes the album feel unfinished in a compelling way. It is not simply an artifact of what happened. It is an artifact of what might have happened if the scene, the label, and the songwriting had aligned at the right moment.

The verdict is in the edit

There is a great EP trapped inside this good album.

Little Monsters is easy to enjoy. It is well played, cleanly produced, and full of evidence that Holland had real capabilities. Tom Holland can sing. Michael Angelo Batio can certainly play. The rhythm section keeps the material moving. The album never becomes a slog.

But the gap between the strongest songs and the more formula-driven tracks is hard to ignore. When Holland leans into melody, texture, and the band’s Midwestern personality, the album sounds distinct. When it leans toward conventional hard-rock mechanics, the songs can begin to blur into material that could have come from a dozen other mid-’80s bands.

“Lovin’ on Time,” “Middle of a Dream,” “Borderline,” “Sacrifice,” “Gotta Run,” and “Keep It to Yourself” form a compelling alternate version of Little Monsters. That version is leaner, stranger, more melodic, and more likely to make you wonder why Holland did not get a longer run.

Was the album too early for the hooks it needed? Did Atlantic fail to find the right lane for a Chicago hard-rock band in a Los Angeles moment? Or did the band simply need one more record to turn its best ideas into a complete statement?

Listen to the full episode for our final rating, then tell us where you land. Is Little Monsters a lost album, a better EP, or a record that deserved a second swing at the late-’80s hard-rock boom?

Episode Highlights

• 00:44: The community poll, how Holland emerged from a tie with L.A. Guns

• 01:40: The short, elusive history of Holland and the Chicago connection

• 02:22: Michael Angelo Batio before Nitro, technical guitar with restraint

• 02:37: “Wake Up the Neighborhood,” Girls Just Want to Have Fun, and Holland’s unexpected soundtrack legacy

• 03:09: “High Life,” “Sacrifice,” and the record’s shifting hard-rock influences

• 03:45: “I Want It,” the closer that could have been a bigger single

• 04:04: Where the record loses focus, and why the choruses do not always land

• 04:50: The final assessment, a better EP hiding inside a full-length album

• 05:13: Chicago versus Los Angeles, and the career Holland never got to build

But this ballot tells a different story.

There’s Wishbone Ash’s Argus, a 1972 record whose twin-guitar harmonies quietly helped lay groundwork for the metal bands that would dominate the next decade. There’s Rose Tattoo’s self-titled 1978 debut, all sweat, slide guitar, and Australian pub-rock danger—the kind of raw, lived-in hard rock that would echo loudly in Guns N’ Roses. There’s Starz’s Violation, a band with KISS-world connections, Jack Douglas behind the board, and every reason to be bigger than they were. And then there’s 1994:’s self-titled album, a melodic hard-rock record from 1978 that feels almost unnervingly like it arrived from the mid-’80s ahead of schedule.

That is the real pleasure of digging into the decade: not replaying the consensus, but finding the forks in the road. These are four records from four different versions of the ’70s—the prog-to-metal bridge, the barroom hard-rock lifers, the almost-made-it arena contenders, and the band that seemed to hear the future before the rest of the industry caught up.

One of them will become the next full Dig Me Out episode: the story behind the band, the record’s place in the larger rock map, our review, host ratings, and the community verdict.

The September 70s ballot

Rose Tattoo — Rose Tattoo (1978)

Suggested by Gavin Reid

Before there was Guns N’ Roses, there was Rose Tattoo: hard-living, no-frills Australian rock ’n’ roll with a fistful of slide guitar and zero interest in polishing the dirt off its boots.

Gavin calls them a cornerstone of Australian rock and points straight to “Nice Boys,” the song that helped put the “Rose” in Guns N’ Roses. If you want to hear a band whose influence runs from the pub-rock circuit to Sunset Strip, this is the record with the bootprints.

1994: — 1994: (1978)

Suggested by Keith P. Miller

A band named 1994: releasing a record in 1978 that sounds like it showed up five or six years early? That is already the kind of timeline glitch Dig Me Out was made to investigate.

Keith hears big hooks, polished songwriting, arena-ready choruses, and a melodic hard-rock/AOR sound that would have made far more commercial sense in the mid-’80s. At the center is Karen Lawrence: powerful, soulful, and apparently overdue for a serious reappraisal. Start with “Once Again,” then ask yourself how this one didn’t become a staple.

Starz — Violation (1977)

Suggested by jdziak

This one has the kind of résumé that should have made it impossible to miss.

Bill Aucoin—KISS’s manager—was behind Starz. They toured with KISS. Guitarist Richie Ranno played on Gene Simmons’ solo record. Jack Douglas produced Violation. And yet, as the nomination puts it, they still got totally buried.

So: was Violation a lost hard-rock contender that got swallowed by the sheer volume of late-’70s rock releases? Or is it a perfect example of why connections, touring slots, and big-name production still can’t guarantee a lasting place in the story? Let’s put it on the table.

Wishbone Ash — Argus (1972)

Suggested by Chip

Prog? Folk rock? Hard rock? Argus lives in the fertile collision zone where those labels stop being useful and the guitars take over.

Chip’s nomination gets right to the point: Wishbone Ash’s twin-guitar approach would become a major part of the language for bands like Judas Priest and Iron Maiden. Steve Harris has specifically pointed fans toward Argus to understand Maiden’s early harmony-guitar sound. There is even the wonderfully strange side note that its cover may have helped inspire Darth Vader’s design.

If this is one of the records that helped teach heavy metal how two guitars could speak at once, it deserves our attention.

What if gothic rock’s grandest record arrived just arrived at the wrong time?

Released on September 24, 1990, Elizium was the third studio album from English goth-rock institution Fields of the Nephilim. It came out through Beggars Banquet, was co-produced by the band and Andy Jackson, and landed at the exact moment popular rock was about to be rewritten. Within a year, the old map would be burned up by Nirvana, grunge, alternative radio, and a much different idea of what darkness in rock music could sound like.

But Elizium lives in the gap before all that. It belongs to a 1990 when a band could still make a long, deeply theatrical record that asks for patience, headphones, darkness, and maybe a country road after midnight.

The Darkest Record Without Punishment

The surprise is how inviting this album is.

The cover, the name, and titles like “(Dead But Dreaming),” “Submission,” and “Sumerland (What Dreams May Come)” announce something ominous. Before hearing a note, we expected any number of directions: black metal, industrial, doom, perhaps some kind of impenetrable occult-rock exercise.

Instead, Elizium comes in with atmosphere, melody, dynamics, and an almost disarming beauty. The album’s darkness is never merely punitive. It does not bludgeon you, nor does it rely on extreme vocals or a wall of distortion to create dread. It pulls you closer.

That difference matters. The record’s most powerful quality is its ability to feel foreboding while remaining accessible. There are reverbed guitars, deep bass, synth haze, chant-like passages, whispered textures, and a voice that seems to rise from somewhere below the floorboards. Yet the songs are built around rhythms and melodies sturdy enough to keep us from getting lost in the smoke.

At the center is Carl McCoy, whose low, gravelly vocal brings the record’s mystery into focus. His performance is more than gothic crooning. He whispers, rasps, declaims, recedes, and periodically makes spoken passages feel genuinely weighty instead of theatrical for its own sake. Strip that voice away, and the music might still be beautiful. But it would not carry the same sense of danger.

The band’s reputation for dust-coated Spaghetti Western imagery, occult symbolism, Biblical reference points, and old-world mysticism can make them seem like an acquired taste. On Elizium, though, the imagery becomes part of the music’s physical space. You do not need a glossary of Sumerian mythology to feel what it is doing.

You only need to be willing to let it take over the room.

Goth Rock Went Cinematic

This album is less a collection of songs than a place to enter.

The official track list is just eight pieces, but Elizium is sequenced like one long, three-act experience: “(Dead But Dreaming),” “For Her Light,” “At the Gates of Silent Memory,” “(Paradise Regained),” “Submission,” “Sumerland (What Dreams May Come),” “Wail of Sumer,” and “And There Will Your Heart Be Also.”

The first stretch establishes the terrain. “(Dead But Dreaming)” is a brief threshold, an ambient opening scene rather than a conventional song. Then “For Her Light” arrives with a bracing, almost unexpectedly direct momentum. There are hints of 1980s-era Rush in the reverbed guitar attack and bass movement, even as McCoy’s voice immediately puts the music somewhere much darker.

From there, Elizium expands rather than repeats. “At the Gates of Silent Memory” pushes the record into a more patient and immersive mode, and “(Paradise Regained)” functions like another passageway. The band is not chasing choruses or radio hooks. They are building a sequence of rooms.

That is why calling it a full-album listen is not snobbery. It is practical listening advice. Starting at track four is a little like walking into a film halfway through and wondering why everyone is speaking in symbols. The record’s drama comes from accumulation: guitar tones bleeding into keyboard tones, drums pushing forward then disappearing into atmosphere, phrases returning in altered form.

The second half makes that structure even clearer. “Sumerland (What Dreams May Come)” runs more than 11 minutes, but it earns the length by shifting internal gears. There is a riff that evokes Eagles’ “Life in the Fast Lane” if it had been dragged through a fog machine and abandoned at the edge of an ancient temple. Then the song opens into something bigger, including a guitar solo with a flash of classic 1980s hard-rock excess.

That is the appeal of Fields of the Nephilim. They can make the sacred and the ridiculous touch shoulders without collapsing the mood.

The Pink Floyd Connection Is Real

The production is not merely “very 1990.” It is the sound of a band using that era’s tools to create a permanent fog.

Elizium was co-produced and engineered by Andy Jackson, whose long association with Pink Floyd explains some of the record’s scale, depth, and carefully layered ambiguity. Jackson’s work gives the album a strange physical character. A sustained sound might be guitar, synthesizer, or an EBow, the electromagnetic device that creates a bowed, sustained guitar effect. Sometimes it is hard to tell, and that is precisely the point.

The album was recorded at Park Gate Studios in Battle, with additional recording and mixing at Astoria, David Gilmour’s houseboat studio at Hampton Court. That detail makes sense the minute you hear the record. Elizium is not attempting to mimic Pink Floyd, but it shares a willingness to make studio technique part of the storytelling. discogs

The reverb, delay, and wide-open spaces initially read as a very specific 1990 production fingerprint. On a first spin, parts can feel thin or washed out, especially if you are listening casually or at low volume. Turn it up, though, and the mix begins to reveal why it was constructed this way. The effects are not decoration. They are the atmosphere itself.

A more forceful remaster might make the entry point easier. At the same time, drying this album out or trying to make it overly punchy would risk ruining its spell. Elizium needs its blur. It needs the sense that the band is playing somewhere just out of view.

It is a record that rewards an actual listening environment: speakers with some air around them, headphones that can handle the low end, or a long nighttime drive when the headlights only reach as far as the next patch of fog.

The Last Great Goth Holdout

By 1990, many of goth’s most important bands were moving elsewhere. Fields of the Nephilim doubled down.

The group emerged in Stevenage, Hertfordshire, in 1984, during a period when the roots of goth rock were already branching out in several directions. Bauhaus had fractured, with members moving into Love and Rockets and solo work. The Cure had become increasingly expansive and pop-facing. Siouxsie and the Banshees were evolving beyond any fixed genre label. The Cult had transformed from their Southern Death Cult beginnings into a much more hard-rocking machine.

Fields of the Nephilim did not exactly preserve goth in amber. They made it bigger, stranger, and more progressive. Their sound had hard-rock muscle, ambient patience, post-punk tension, psychedelic color, and the kind of theatrical commitment that could become laughable in lesser hands. Somehow, on Elizium, it never does.

It helps that the band was fully committed to the mythology. The songs invoke Biblical, occult, mystical, and Sumerian imagery. The band’s visual world brought together dusters, flour-covered faces, dark cowboy silhouettes, and a Sergio Leone-like sense of desert ritual. McCoy even appears in Richard Stanley’s 1990 cyberpunk film Hardware, wearing what was essentially his stage persona on screen.

That total commitment is a big part of why the album works. Fields of the Nephilim were not trying to sell us an attitude for a single cycle. They had built a world and were still living in it.

The American market largely missed them. But their influence is easier to hear in hindsight, in later gothic rock, darkwave, industrial, black metal, and even strands of emo that treated atmosphere as something more than an intro before the chorus arrives.

The Beautiful Problem With Elizium

The album’s greatest strength can also be its barrier.

There is no easy single to grab the first-time listener by the collar. “For Her Light” and “(Paradise Regained)” have more immediate propulsion, but Elizium is not designed as a playlist machine. It asks for a full immersion, which means it can take time to find its way in.

That also makes the long closing stretch a challenge. “Wail of Sumer” and “And There Will Your Heart Be Also” create a nearly 14-minute final descent, with a persistent bass foundation and a deep commitment to repetition. If you are locked into its mood, the effect is hypnotic. If you are evaluating each section for a new hook, tempo shift, or payoff, it can feel like the record is asking you to float a little longer than you planned.

The production has a similar tradeoff. Its haze is a feature, not a flaw, but it may initially sound distant or thin to listeners raised on hyper-compressed modern rock records. This is not gym music. It is not ideal for scanning tracks while doing something else. It rewards volume and attention.

The community response captured that tension well. One listener heard “heavy goth storytelling,” another compared the production atmosphere to Joy Division’s Closer with a touch of Queensrÿche, and another loved the album while admitting that 30 minutes at a time might be enough.

That is an honest reaction. You may not play Elizium every day. But when you want an album to turn the lights down and turn the world sideways, few records do it better.

Worth Entering the Fog

Elizium is the kind of overlooked record that makes our usual categories feel too small. It is a gothic rock album, certainly, but it is also a progressive rock suite, a dark ambient experience, a late-1980s production artifact, a headphone record, a Halloween record, and a reminder that 1990 held more possibilities than the history books tend to admit.

For longtime fans, this has often been treated as Fields of the Nephilim’s masterpiece. For us, it was a genuine discovery, especially because it found a way to feel ominous without becoming oppressive. The atmosphere is dense, but the record has air in it. The vocal is unmistakable, but the instrumental work is equally essential. The mysticism is everywhere, but you never need to decode every reference for the mood to land.

So the real questions are these:

• Does Elizium work as one continuous experience, or do you need a few standout tracks to come back to?

• Is this the perfect entry point to gothic rock, or too deep into the fog for a newcomer?

• Does the 1990 production sound dated, timeless, or somehow both?

• And which Fields of the Nephilim album should we hear next: Dawnrazor, The Nephilim, or something later?

Listen to the full episode for our final verdict, then tell us where Elizium takes you in the comments.

Episode Highlights

• 00:00:46: Keith Tasker returns with his pick, Fields of the Nephilim’s Elizium

• 00:02:10: Nephilim mythology, occult imagery, and the band’s theatrical foundations

• 00:04:38: Carl McCoy in Hardware, plus the band’s cinematic Spaghetti Western visual world

• 00:06:05: Andy Jackson, Pink Floyd connections, and why the production feels so enormous

• 00:07:30: Jay and Tim go in cold, expecting metal or industrial and finding something else

• 00:09:38: Why Elizium works as three movements instead of eight conventional songs

• 00:15:39: What works, accessible darkness, Rush-like guitar textures, and McCoy’s voice

• 00:20:26: A beautiful, ethereal, enveloping headphone record

• 00:26:38: Keith explains why this is an album experience, not a track-picking record

• 00:30:09: Aleister Crowley, Hardware, Richard Stanley, and the larger Nephilim universe

• 00:34:19: What does not work, thinness, reverb, and the challenge of the extended finale

• 00:42:20: The record as a three-part journey through death, submission, and acceptance

• 00:45:12: Final verdicts, three worthy albums and one lifelong obsession

• 00:47:53: Why Elizium belongs on the ultimate Halloween playlist

And after all that?

A tie between two records with very different stories behind them.

The first-round results

• Holland — Little Monsters | 31.25%

• L.A. Guns — Cocked & Loaded | 31.25%

• Tesla — The Great Radio Controversy | 25.00%

• Guns N’ Roses — Lies| 12.50%

Tesla made a serious late push. Joe Royland made a persuasive case that The Great Radio Controversy avoided the sophomore slump and improved on Tesla’s debut. But prior Dig Me Out coverage of Mechanical Resonance clearly factored into some voting. And while Guns N’ Roses had their defenders, Lies could not overcome the record’s dated, controversial material for several voters.

Which leaves us with the two albums that sparked the most interesting argument.

The case for Holland

Holland is the record on this ballot that feels like a genuine Dig Me Out mission: a riff-heavy Chicago hard-rock album that seemed built for bigger things, then slipped away before enough people got the chance to hear it.

Scott Halgirm put it simply: “So Holland.”

Gavin called Little Monsters “pretty good,” but said its obscurity was what tipped the scale: “Which leaves Holland for the win, plus it’s pretty good.”

Kyle Bittner had never heard the band, but the mystery—and that cover—was enough: “Rolling with the majority and going with Holland. Never heard of them and the cover is wicked.”

For Mike Androff, it was more than a discovery. He remembered Holland getting regular play on Chicago’s Real Precious Metal radio in the mid-’80s, especially “Gotta Run” and “Wake Up the Neighborhood,” and called the album formative to his growing metal and hard-rock tastes.

Joe Royland also pointed out that Little Monsters features the lead guitar work of future shred fixture Michael Angelo Batio. That is exactly the kind of loose thread Dig Me Out likes to pull: a band with the songs, the players, and the regional momentum—then no obvious second chapter.

The case for L.A. Guns

Then there is Cocked & Loaded: not a mystery, exactly, but a record with enough hooks, grit, and guitar swagger to keep earning another listen.

Jacob Miller got right to the point: “Only reason I am not doing Tesla is because Mechanical Resonance was already done. gimme LA Guns.”

That is the L.A. Guns argument. If Holland is the band that might have been huge, Cocked & Loaded is the record that knew exactly what it was trying to do and did it with a sneer, a chorus, and a guitar riff that arrives wearing sunglasses indoors.

Scott’s critique is fair—“Cocked n Loaded has its moments but pretty inconsistent”—but it still made enough of a case to finish tied for first. That is why we need the runoff.

Vote in the runoff below. It stays open for 24 hours.

The winner becomes the next full Dig Me Out episode and Substack post: the band’s story, the album review, the ratings, the community score, and the comments that helped put it there.

Subscribe now

That is the disorienting pleasure of The Space Ritual Alive in Liverpool and London, commonly shortened to Space Ritual. Released in May 1973 by United Artists Records, it was Hawkwind’s fourth album, a live double set assembled from performances at Liverpool Stadium and the Brixton Sundown in late 1972. It reached No. 9 on the UK Albums Chart, an astonishing result for an 86-minute collision of fuzz riffs, electronics, spoken-word science fiction, saxophone, flute, and long stretches where the song seems less interested in ending than escaping Earth’s gravity.

Hawkwind won the Dig Me Out poll with 43 percent of the combined vote, ahead of Nick Gilder’s City Nights, Irish Skid Row’s 34 Hours, and Bloodrock’s Bloodrock U.S.A. The album was suggested by Eric Peterson, and it gave all three of us a chance to confront a band we mostly knew through one looming name: Lemmy.

Suggest an Album

Before Motörhead Had a Name

Lemmy is not hiding in the background here.

Before he formed Motörhead, Lemmy Kilmister played bass for Hawkwind from 1971 to 1975. On Space Ritual, that bass is not merely holding down the root notes while the rest of the band floats away. It is a snarling, overdriven force, loud in the mix and constantly moving, often sounding like the engine beneath the entire spacecraft.

The strange thing is that Hawkwind does not sound much like Motörhead. This is not a rehearsal tape for “Ace of Spades.” It is slower, looser, murkier, and far more willing to let a riff repeat until it becomes hypnotic. Yet the clues are there. The aggressive pick attack, the distortion, the way the bass can carry a melody and a riff at the same time, all point toward what Lemmy would eventually turn into something louder, leaner, and absolutely unforgiving.

That is the fun archaeological dig inside this record. Strip away the spoken passages, the synth wash, the flute, the free-form detours, and some of these riffs could become early Motörhead songs with enough speed, compression, and attitude. Instead, Hawkwind lets them breathe for eight or ten minutes, sometimes longer. It is rock and roll built around propulsion rather than precision.

Subscribe now

This was never meant to be background music.

Hawkwind’s Space Ritual was designed as a full sensory environment, not simply a live document. The original release came with a 32-page booklet, while the stage presentation involved dancers, mimes, lights, electronics, and science-fiction imagery. Michael Moorcock, the acclaimed science-fiction author associated with Hawkwind, contributed poetry and writing to the wider project.

That context matters, because listening digitally can make the record feel like a giant, baffling jam with strange interruptions. In the room, surrounded by strobes, dancers, noise, and a crowd committed to the trip, it was a happening. Hawkwind were not reproducing their studio material cleanly each night. They were creating a theatrical mess, partly structured and partly improvised, with enough moving parts to make even modern arena rock look restrained.

It also explains the album’s biggest challenge. An 86-minute double album asks a lot from a listener who has not already learned Hawkwind’s language. The music flows in and out of itself. A title may repeat until you find the hook, or it may never give you one in the conventional sense. The performance is compelling because it refuses ordinary rock rules, but that refusal can make the record feel like an experience you admire before you fully understand it.

The future is hiding in the feedback.

AllMusic describes Space Ritual as a volatile blend of prog, acid rock, proto-metal, science fiction, fantasy, and jazz, a combination that has aged into something prophetically influential rather than merely dated. That influence is easier to hear when we stop trying to force Hawkwind into the same box as Pink Floyd or Genesis. They may have shared a loose “space rock” designation, but Hawkwind’s music is more physical, more repetitive, and more confrontational.

“Brainstorm” has a violent, droning intensity that feels closer to later underground guitar music than the graceful expansiveness usually associated with progressive rock. “Orgone Accumulator” rides a heavy blues groove that could be a distant ancestor to desert rock, though Hawkwind stretch it into a ten-minute incantation rather than a compact riff rocker. “Space Is Deep” offers the closest thing to a recognizable, recurring melodic center, even as it remains submerged in effects and momentum.

That is why we kept hearing pieces of later bands in it: Sonic Youth, Kyuss, Queens of the Stone Age, Black Rebel Motorcycle Club, even the more exploratory corners of The Verve. It is not that Hawkwind sounds exactly like any of them. It is that the record makes a case for repetition, distortion, and atmosphere as a musical destination rather than just a bridge between verses.

The Songs That Pull You In

Not every orbit needs a map.

“Brainstorm” is the obvious entry point for anyone who wants the volume and physicality behind Hawkwind’s reputation. It is built on a relentless, heavy pulse that makes the band’s proto-metal reputation feel earned. “Lord of Light” stands out for its wild saxophone moments, a reminder that Hawkwind could bring jazz instrumentation into a hard-rock context without making it feel polite.

“Down Through the Night” and “Space Is Deep” provide more identifiable footholds, especially for listeners who need a phrase or chorus-like shape to grab onto. They show that beneath the electronics and cosmic theatre, Hawkwind understood the basic appeal of a riff, a repeated line, and a groove that will not quit.

Then there is “Orgone Accumulator,” which is both part of the appeal and part of the problem. The riff is thick, bluesy, and memorable. The lyric is built around a barrage of rhymes and repetition, making it goofy, oddly catchy, and a little exhausting over its full length. It is a perfect snapshot of Space Ritual: there is a genuinely great idea here, and Hawkwind refuses to leave it alone after three minutes.

The spoken-word interludes create an even stranger push and pull. They break the musical flow, but their cold, sci-fi language gives the whole thing an unnerving cult-object quality. A playlist of the spoken pieces alone might be a bizarrely effective entryway into this world.

Hawkwind found the riff. Then they kept looking.

The record’s excess is inseparable from its identity. Cutting it down into a sharp 40-minute set would make it more accessible, but it would also remove the sense of being trapped in a long, noisy, theatrical voyage. This is not music that politely arrives, makes its point, and leaves. It circles, drifts, blares, and occasionally seems to forget what planet it started on.

Still, a listener does not need to treat Space Ritual as a test of endurance. Sampling it is a completely valid way to experience it. Pull out a few tracks. Start with “Brainstorm,” “Space Is Deep,” “Orgone Accumulator,” and “Lord of Light.” Listen for Lemmy’s bass. Listen for the heavy, single-riff focus that would later emerge in stoner rock and heavy music. Then decide whether you want to spend the remaining hour traveling farther out.

That is also the limitation. The vocal melodies can feel functional rather than commanding, and the lyrics rarely supply the personality that a singer like Lemmy would later bring to a similarly blunt riff. The live presentation was clearly essential to Hawkwind’s power, but a streaming-era listener gets only the audio, not the dancers, lights, booklet, costumes, and collective sensory overload that helped turn the original show into a total artwork.

Subscribe now

Our Verdict Stays in Orbit

This is not an easy record, but it is an unusually revealing one.

Space Ritual is a document of a band testing how far rock music could be pushed before it stopped behaving like conventional rock music. It is also a rare chance to hear Lemmy operating inside a radically different machine, with his future unmistakably present in his bass tone but not yet fully formed in the songs around him.

AllMusic hears an album whose wild mixture of acid rock, proto-metal, science fiction, and jazz has remained influential over time. We hear that influence too, even when the album’s length, spoken passages, and refusal to edit itself make the voyage feel more admirable than repeatable.

Would you want the whole double album, or a carefully selected EP-length passage through the ritual? Does Lemmy sound like Motörhead waiting to happen, or does Hawkwind erase that story more than it confirms it? Which piece of this noisy, cosmic puzzle still lands in 2026?

Listen to the full episode for our final rating, then drop a comment with the track you would put on a proto-stoner-rock sampler.

Episode Highlights

• 00:42: The August 70s poll, four community picks and Hawkwind’s 43 percent victory

• 02:49: What did Hawkwind sound like before anyone pressed play?

• 05:06: The first clear Motörhead breadcrumb, “Motorhead” on Warrior on the Edge of Time

• 12:17: Space Ritual history, the 1973 release, chart run, and live-performance concept

• 16:09: Lemmy’s bass, aggressive, melodic, and impossible to ignore

• 24:42: Why the album feels like interstellar Grateful Dead without sounding like them

• 29:37: “Orgone Accumulator,” rhyming chaos, heavy groove, and ten minutes of commitment

• 37:43: “Brainstorm” as a bridge toward Sonic Youth and later noise rock

• 41:09: Proto-stoner-rock connections, Kyuss, Queens of the Stone Age, and fuzz-heavy repetition

• 51:44: Hawkwind as a theatrical art project rather than a conventional concert

• 55:08: The final debate, worthy double album, better single album, or better EP?

• 01:01:43: The consensus verdict and how to approach the record now

That’s the story running through this month’s ballot. Lies caught Guns N’ Roses in the awkward, combustible space between a debut that changed everything and an impossible follow-up. Cocked & Loaded found L.A. Guns right in the middle of the Sunset Strip machine. Little Monsters made a case for Holland as Chicago’s next big export. And The Great Radio Controversy showed Tesla delivering something more ambitious than their debut.

The contenders

Guns N’ Roses — Lies

Suggested by Keith P. Miller

“Guns N Roses put out this half acoustic half fake live album to try to satisfy fans while they waited for the next album.”

Released in the long shadow of Appetite for Destruction, Lies is a strange, transitional artifact: one side built around a manufactured live atmosphere, the other around acoustic confessionals, barroom swagger, and “Patience.” It is also inseparable from the controversy around its lyrics—a record that invites a conversation about late-’80s hard rock, its blind spots, and what it sounds like from this distance.

L.A. Guns — Cocked & Loaded

Suggested by Richard Waterman

“Classic late 80’s LA sleazy rock/metal”

There is no overthinking this one: Cocked & Loaded is Sunset Strip rock at full velocity. Hooks, leather, danger, and enough sharp-edged guitar work to remind you why L.A. Guns were never just another name on a flyer beneath the headliner.

Holland — Little Monsters

Suggested by Len Anzelde

“Probably the best metal band coming out of Chicago in the 80’s.”

This is exactly why we run these polls. Holland made one album full of catchy, riff-heavy songs that sounded built for wider radio—and then largely disappeared. Little Monsters has the unmistakable pull of a lost contender: the record you find years later and wonder how it slipped through the cracks.

Tesla — The Great Radio Controversy

Suggested by Whitney Beehler

“Great Hard Rock album from a band that gained a lot of attention at the tail end of the 80s Metal craze.”

Tesla arrived when the metal boom was beginning to buckle under its own excess, but The Great Radio Controversy had more muscle and heart than most of its era. It is a big, lived-in hard-rock record that deserves a fresh listen beyond the usual hits-and-hair-metal shorthand.

Your vote makes the episode

Vote for the album you want to hear us pull apart, defend, question, rate, and place back in its proper corner of rock history. The winner across Patreon and Substack becomes the next full Dig Me Out episode—and your comments may wind up in the discussion.

A Second Wave of Post-Punk

Interpol dropped Turn on the Bright Lights in 2002 and lit the fuse for a whole genre of bands mining the same Joy Division and Gang of Four vocabulary. Three years later, in 2005, Bloc Party, Editors, Maxïmo Park and The Bravery all released debuts within the same twelve months, a compressed second wave rather than an early-decade wave. Cut City arrived in 2007, right as Editors and Interpol themselves were already shifting sound, making Exit Decades a late entry into a scene that was already moving on.

The record lives in the friction between locked-in, almost mechanical downstrummed rhythm sections and loose, expressive, clearly human performances layered over top. That contrast, tight and stilted on one hand, propulsive and dynamic on the other, is what keeps nine short songs from blurring together. Vocalist Max Hansson’s baritone floats between rhythmic near-speaking and a croon that occasionally opens up toward melodic alt-rock, drawing comparisons to Suede and Placebo as much as the obvious Joy Division and The Sound touchstones.

Unlike a lot of the foundational post-punk records this album is indebted to, which were often tinny and budget-constrained, Exit Decades benefits from modern recording clarity. Every instrument sits in its own space; the bass acts as a genuine melodic anchor rather than bottom-end filler, and the guitar is deployed sparingly for maximum impact rather than played wall-to-wall. Tracks like “Like Ashes Like Millions,” “Such Verve,” and “Rival Trial” show off a band that knows when to strip back the arrangement and let a broken drum pattern breathe before snapping back into gear.

Subscribe now

There’s a real argument to be made that Cut City showed up to the party after the novelty had worn off. By 2007 the acts that kicked off this revival were already evolving past it, and Cut City never toured outside Sweden, never played the UK, and never really pushed the record commercially. PopMatters’ contemporary review flagged the same tension, noting the album is “effective, if a bit predictable,” and that the band’s fidelity to the source material sometimes reads as “disingenuous” rather than innovative.

What Happened After

Cut City went quiet for stretches rather than breaking up outright. Their second album, Where’s the Harm in Dreams Disarmed, came out in 2012, followed by a ten-year gap before 2022’s Tape Days and 2023’s Honeymoon at the Barricades brought the band back. Members also play in the more punk-leaning project Missiles, described as sharing the post-punk DNA with shorter, faster songs.

Nine songs, thirty-four minutes, and the discussion kept circling one question: does this record have the killer single or quirky vocal hook that made its American and British peers stick? Fan and critic sentiment splits along that exact line, PopMatters called it “straight throwback” with “limited appeal,” while Discogs users currently rate the album a very healthy 4.77 out of 5. We debated whether the hooks are there and just underdeveloped, or whether the sonic performance and mix quality carry the record on their own. Does a record need a “Love Will Tear Us Apart” moment to be memorable, or is atmosphere enough? And does arriving three years after the trend peaked actually hurt an album, or just make it a footnote worth digging up now? Listen to the full episode to hear where we landed, and drop a comment with your own take.

Episode Highlights

• 00:00: Intro, welcome back guest Darren Leach and his history with the show

• 01:49: Darren introduces Cut City and Exit Decades, released 2007

• 02:20: How Darren discovered the album on a blog in the late 2000s

• 04:51: Band background, Deleted Art, Gold Standard Laboratories, discography timeline

• 08:51: Jay breaks down the mechanical vs. expressive tension in the arrangements

• 14:16: Tim on the baritone vocal style and comparisons to Richard Butler and The Sound

• 19:05: Darren on the mix, bass as melodic anchor, and “Rival Trial”

• 26:49: What doesn’t work: the missing killer vocal hook

• 33:09: Mapping the post-punk revival timeline against Interpol, Bloc Party, Editors

• 37:41: Hosts reveal ratings and share the Patreon poll result

A Memphis band born out of Free Beer

Surprise Attack is the debut studio album from Tora Tora, a hard rock band formed in Memphis, Tennessee in 1985, released in May 1989 on A&M Records and produced by Joe Hardy and Paul Ebersold. According to a Headbangers Ball interview, a friend of the band handed them a list of 60 to 70 possible band names, and Tora Tora was the one that stuck; the group’s original name had reportedly been Free Beer. Frontman Anthony Corder and guitarist Keith Douglas anchored a lineup that, unlike most of the Sunset Strip class of 1989, wasn’t jockeying for space against Poison, Warrant, and Mötley Crüe. Being 10 years removed from the epicenter of hair metal and working out of Memphis instead of Los Angeles let their influences run closer to Aerosmith and Judas Priest without the scene politics diluting them.

Judas Priest power wrapped in Beale Street blues

What makes Surprise Attack stand apart from the era’s cookie cutter glam records is the way it fuses two things that shouldn’t fit together this cleanly: chunky, Judas Priest style power metal riffing and loose, Aerosmith style blues shuffle. Songs like “One for the Road” flip between the two feels within the same track rather than settling into either lane. “Being There” opens with a Leslie organ tone that gives it a soulful, almost 70s texture before the chorus turns into a chugging metal hook, a nonstandard spin on the power ballad formula that trades polish for grit. “Walkin’ Shoes” builds its hook by reusing the same riff in the intro and chorus but cutting it short in the verse, a small structural trick that keeps the song’s signature lick from wearing out its welcome.

A&M pulled three singles from the record: “Walkin’ Shoes,” “Guilty,” and “Phantom Rider”, and the trio doesn’t sound like a single band phoning in three versions of the same song. “Guilty” carries a five-to-ten-second stretch of unusually chunky, distorted guitar after the first chorus that never repeats anywhere else on the record, a moment specific enough that it landed on mixtapes for years. “Phantom Rider” leans hard into a Bad Company style groove that stands apart from the glossier singles around it. The album reached number 47 on the Billboard 200, modest by hair metal standards but enough to get the band on the road opening for LA Guns, then for The Cult on the Sonic Temple tour alongside Bonham, and for date runs with Great White.

The record’s biggest obstacle isn’t the songwriting, it’s the mix. Reverb and delay sit over nearly everything, to the point that bass playing, organ parts, and even guitar solos get buried in a wash rather than cutting through. Compared to a band like Badlands, which stripped its production down to emphasize raw performance, Surprise Attack sounds like it defaulted to the standard late-80s hard rock settings rather than chasing the drier, punchier tone the songs seem built for. It is the kind of album that rewards a remix or remaster candidate conversation, because the performances underneath the haze, particularly the vocal and guitar work, hold up better than the mix lets on.

The verdict

Community sentiment on this album splits hard. Some listeners call Surprise Attack an underrated great that got unfairly lumped into the tail end of the hair glam era despite not really belonging there. Others have a much colder read, with one commenter recalling mercilessly mocking the band’s friends over the record back in the day. Even a Wikipedia-linked contemporary review dismissed it as a Van Halen and Dokken knockoff, a comparison our hosts pushed back on hard. So does the deeper album justify the singles that made it a modest hit, or do the singles carry a record that gets less memorable the further you go? Is the reverb-heavy 1989 production a dealbreaker or just a product of its time? And which handful of songs would actually survive a trim? The hosts weighed in with a real verdict on this one, ranking it somewhere between a worthy full album and a tighter, stronger EP. Listen to the episode for the full ratings breakdown, and drop a comment with where you’d land.

What happened to the band

Tora Tora followed Surprise Attack with 1992’s Wild America, then largely dissolved as the industry’s tastes swung toward grunge. In the years since, the label FNA has released a string of compilations and unreleased material, including Bombs Away: The Unreleased Surprise Attack Recordings, and the band reunited to release The Bastards of Beale on Frontiers Records in 2019, followed by a live acoustic EP. Corder still plays regional dates around Ohio, where local Columbus musician Charlie Bonnet III has opened several of the reunion shows.

Episode Highlights

• Intro - "Walkin' Shoes"

• 00:00: Poll results, Tora Tora wins the four-way poll with 50% of the vote against Metallica, Slade, and Motörhead

• 04:18: Band history, hosts share their personal history with Tora Tora and the second album Wild America

• 06:35: Tour bus story, a firsthand account of interviewing the band in 1992 before a Newport headlining show

• 20:39: What works, breaking down the blend of Judas Priest style riffs and bluesy grooves across the record

• 23:19 - "One for the Road"

• 24:53 - "Being There"

• 32:31 - "Guilty"

• 33:34 - "Walkin' Shoes"

• 35:16 - "Riverside Drive"

• 39:34: Band name origin, the list of 60 to 70 names and the Free Beer backstory

• 40:04: What doesn’t work, a deep dive on the album’s reverb-heavy 1989 production

• 47:28: Legacy, the FNA reissue campaign, Bombs Away, and the 2019 reunion album The Bastards of Beale

• 49:43: Final verdict, worthy album, better EP, or decent single

• Outro - “Hard Times”

Four heavy records from the ’70s. Four different entry points into the decade. One winner gets the full Dig Me Out treatment: history, deep dive, host ratings, community ratings, and the comments that keep the conversation going.

Paid members: this is your ballot. You’re not just picking a record for us to talk about—you’re deciding what gets made next.

Subscribe now

Hawkwind — Space Ritual (1973)

Suggested by Eric Peterson

“The DNA of stoner rock, weird, sci-fi, psych, and even trance can be found on this recording.”

Hawkwind weren’t just playing hard rock; they sounded like they were trying to transmit it from a damaged spacecraft somewhere beyond the moon. Space Ritual is the definitive early live document from the British space-rock institution: proto-punk velocity, psychedelic drift, sci-fi atmosphere, and riffs that feel built to shake loose a few ceiling tiles.

Eric makes a strong case that this is the right doorway into Hawkwind beyond “Silver Machine” and “Urban Guerrilla.” If you want to hear a record where heavy psych, punk, stoner rock, and cosmic repetition are all beginning to bleed together, this is the one.

Skid Row — 34 Hours (1971)

Suggested by Gavin Reid

“The ’70s Irish Skid Row is a mix of rock, proto-metal, psychedelic and prog sounds, to create something you’ll want to hear.”

No, not that Skid Row. This is the early-’70s Irish band with a young Gary Moore, playing before the legend had fully arrived but with plenty of evidence already on tape.

34 Hours is what happens when blues-rock muscle, psychedelic wandering, proto-metal crunch, and prog curiosity all decide to pile into the same van. Gavin’s “maybe even a supergroup” thought is hard to shake—especially knowing where Moore would go from here. This is the sound of a guitarist and a band testing every possible route before the map was finished.

Bloodrock — Bloodrock U.S.A. (1971)

Suggested by Kyle Bittner

“My dad, who passed a few years ago, had this in his collection and when I was younger I was enamored with the cover art, but obviously hated the music at the time.”

Sometimes the hook is a riff. Sometimes it’s an album cover that burns itself into your brain before you’re old enough to understand what the music is doing.

Kyle rediscovered Bloodrock U.S.A. through exactly that kind of family-memory detour: a record from his late father’s collection, remembered first for its artwork and then found again years later with different ears. He came back to it, dug into Bloodrock’s catalog, and found an album that feels ready for another shot.

And yes, Kyle is also right about the cover: it makes an immediate, extremely persuasive case for itself.

Nick Gilder — City Nights (1978)

Suggested by Whitney Beehler

“Chunky, glammy power pop songs including ‘Hot Child in the City,’ ‘(She’s) One of the Boys’ and ‘Got to Get Out.’”

Need some glitter with your guitar muscle? Whitney Beehler brings City Nights, an album packed with glossy hooks, chunky guitars, and enough glam swagger to make the whole ballot lean toward the mirror.

“Hot Child in the City” is the obvious calling card, but City Nights has more to offer than one massive single. It’s power pop with a little grit under the polish—the kind of record that makes a strong argument that catchy doesn’t mean lightweight.

Cast Your Vote

One of these albums becomes the next full Dig Me Out episode. We’ll get into the band, the record, the ratings, the poll fallout, and the community takes that deserve to be heard.

Paid members, cast your vote now. You get voting power, a place in the comments, and a real hand in deciding what we dig into next.

Subscribe now

Which album would hurt the most to see lose—and what song from it still gets you every time?